Who's The Best Out Of These 4 QB?

Question

In terms of fantasy, who's the best out of these 4 QB?:

-Matt Hasselbeck

-Derek Anderson

-Eli Manning

-David Garrard

Thanks!

Answer 1

Anderson is a hit or miss, didn't play all that great in the preseason, so for fantasy value it would have to be Hasselbeck.

Answer 2

deffinatly not manning...

gerrard doesnt have too much of a recieving core with him

for this year i have to go with derek anderson

Answer 3

Anderson

Answer 4

anderson but garrard is a sleeper qb and could have a great season so either one

Answer 5

Derek Anderson or Eli Manning

Answer 6

Here's the breakdown...

Hasselbeck- Solid, always solid but there top two recievers are out atleast the first 4-6 games and he's also has minor back issues but dont worry he'll still put up solid numbers

Anderson- Rough preseason for the browns...anderbewareson with a concussion and edwards with a bad cut on his foot from racing donte stallworth in practice with no shoes on....hmmm their the most notable guys but if the cobwebs go away for anderson an this offense gets clicking with that top notch offensive line i think he could have another big year...top 5, well this preseason start hasnt helped...right outside the top 5...maybe....

Eli- The top two defensive players are gone now for the year, one with an injury an one retiring.... the defense kept that team together....your rolling the dice with eli... an the house always wins

Garrard- Very consistent and doesnt make mistakes. His receiving core has improved atleast on paper an they still have the two headed monster of jones drew and taylor. Garrard is solid but will rarely give you 3 or 4 td passing days....he'll hover around 190 yards passing and 1 or 2 throwing. ( he's mobile so 1 or 2 rushing might get in there too)

Whatever you like here go with and enjoy the ride...goodluck

TLam

Answer 7

hasselbeck. his underrated. After that i would say Anderson but he could be hit or miss, he only has one yr experience. Then i would go Eli and put Garrard at the bottom

Answer 8

Derek Anderson hasn't looked good this preseason, Eli Manning isn't an elite fantasy QB just yet even after the SB win, Garrard hasn't played a full season as a starting QB so Hasselbeck wins by default.

Answer 9

all real close but anderson ahead a little