Who's a better Phantom: Gerard Butler or John Cudia?

Question

Who's a better Phantom: Gerard Butler or John Cudia?

Answer 1

C. None of the Above. I prefer the Canterville Ghost. Quite amusing...

;)

I guess I would take Cudia.

Answer 2

Okay.....this should not be in the form of a question. It goes like this: The BEST Phantom IS Gerard Butler. Actually, I don't even know who John Cudia is, but you just can't beat Gerard Butler.

Answer 3

for me both

Answer 4

HUH?

Answer 5

Have you ever heard Cudia sing?  If so, you wouldn't even ask this question.  Gerard is great looking, but doesn't do the part justice musically.  Cudia is outstanding!

Answer 6

Gerard Butler all the way....!!! How is that a question??? haha