Who's better : Greg Inglis or Nigel Vagana from 2002?

Question

Now keep in mind, dont leave stupid comments praising Inglis but actually think before you answer!

btw Vagana scored 5 tries in one match that year.

Answer 1

Well Vangana in 2002 was exceptional and Inglis was only a baby on the boob but.... Inglis to have such skill at such a young age is phenominal vangana was what 22? in 02' may be wrong :-p but inglis is only set to get better from here he has that amazing fend where he'll palm someone on his left sid with his Right hand reaching across the body and past the ball..... pure skill.... You cannot teach that although.....

Good question...... VERY CLOSE

Answer 2

Vagana always struck me as a defensive liability. For every 2 tries he scored - he would be responsible for 1 getting scored.

Answer 3

personal opinion.. Inglis is better. He has been labelled a freak from the very start of his career and is consistent.. he had a down patch but look at him now.. back to the Inglis we know!! The thing is, you can never compare... we all have different opinions and will never agree... put it this way.. no two players are the same

Answer 4

Greg Inglis is the better player as he is great at any possition he plays with his height flexability and speed.The 5 tries doesnt mean anything to compare players.

Answer 5

Greg Inglis is my  choice, he sets up tries & finishes them.

Nigel Vagana - he never sets up tries he finishes them, he might have been a star in 2002 but did nothing when he played with the Sharks just bludged.

Answer 6

Inglis ball skills are unbelievable.  Add to that the speed and his football brain.

Answer 7

Well I would say It's Vangana because he is an experience player as for Inglis he is strong and fast.

Answer 8

They are both great players ,Greg being a lot younger and far less experienced, so it may be a bit early in his career to compare him with someone that`s been in the game as long and scored as many try`s as Nigel has.

PS,  I used their first names rather than surnames......just in case I spelled Nigel`s surname wrong.........you know..... with that bit of hair on his chin..........Brazilian`s are in Nigel.

Answer 9

who are they?

i thought about it