Who's gonna have a better season: Aaron Rodgers or Kurt Warner?

Question

Who's gonna have a better season: Aaron Rodgers or Kurt Warner?

Answer 1

Kurt because of Matt's poor pre-season performance Kurt will be given more time and since most teams will realize that Aaron is just like a rookie starting his first games and will put the pressure on him -  hard and force him to make bad decisions.

Answer 2

I think Kurt Warner.  Aaron Rodgers is totally unknown.  Kurt Warner has great receivers and will continue off where he left off last season.

Answer 3

Warner without a doubt.

Answer 4

As much as I wish it was the other way around, I have to say Kurt Warner.

Kurt Warner is on the Cardinals, a team that is pass-happy, to say the least. You add a guy like Boldin on one side, and Larry Fitzgerald on the other, and you have everything you need to be successful. Their line is questionable, but it is solid enough to get Warner the three seconds he needs to hit a man. Warner is a true vet. He knows how to win. He showed that in St. Louis. I'm not saying that that is what will happen in the desert, but I do think Arizona is better than most give them credit for.

If Warner can't get time to throw, though, he is terrible. He is one of the slowest guys in the league, and, as a quarterback, that is the last thing you want people to know about you. If he can't get the time to throw, he will get rushed left and right, fumbling, throwing picks, and making stupid mistakes.

Rodgers, on the other hand, is completely unproven. As a Cal fan, I know that he has the talent to get it done. I just dont know if he will get the true chance. I can see the Packers handing it off to Ryan Grant a million times a game, just to avoid the Aaron Rodgers' turnovers. Even when they do drop back, there are going to be problems. Donald Driver has said on record that it is wierd catching Rodgers. He is used to the Brett Favre ball, as is everybody on that team, and when you take away one of the best quarterbacks of our generation, you are bound for trouble.

There is going to be, without a doubt, a learning curve for the entire Packers team. If it takes a while to happen, which I think it may, Rodgers will be sitting there with average stats while Warner tears it up down under.

Answer 5

aaron, cause kurt will be benched for leinart after a few games.

Answer 6

Aaron Rodgers. Kurt Warner in my opinion has been to inconsistent. Lost his spot to marc bulger i believe with the rams, eli manning with the giants and then matt linart with the cards. Give it 4 games and matt will get his team back. Aaron Rodgers has spent the last 3 years watching and learning from the best quarterback to ever play the game. Greg Jennings will be there to help Rodgers shine. The next Marvin Harrison and Peyton Manning combo.

Answer 7

Kurt Warner is sorta washed up now. He will have a normal season that many QB's his age have. Probably more interceptions then passes and if he is lucky his stats will be even. Aaron Rodgers seems to be a great young prospect. I will have to say Aaron.

Answer 8

Kurt Warner because Aaron Rodgers will still be looking over his shoulder to see if Brett Farve shows up. (LOL)

Answer 9

Aaron Rodgers

Answer 10

Warner, if given the chance.

Answer 11

Aaron Rodgers of course, even though he has been in the league for a couple of seasons now, he is getting his first starting year as quarterback.  Kurt Warner, although faced with a harder schedule, is a veteran, and knows the responsibility of being a team's quarterback