Who's the most overrated player in NFL???

Question

Who's the most overrated player in NFL???

Answer 1

derrick anderson or Brett Favre.

Jeez all of you people hate Tony Romo, and give me a reason why...The cowboys clinched home field through out, and even though he lost to the Giants in the first round, so did the worlds second biggest celebrity (next to Barrack Obama, ha) Brett Favre.  And the Giants were obviously worthy oponents, did they not go on to beat the patriots??

Im just sick of everyone hating tony romo for very little reason, probably just because there team isnt as good as the cowboys, or maybe because there was a picture takin of him on vacation with Jessica Simpson.  

Go Lions

Answer 2

Reggie Bush

Answer 3

BUSH and Mcnabb. i grew up in philly and always hated mcnabb. he just had a h**l of a team surrounding him to make him look good. bush has shown nothing spectacular yet but you never know. I am a chiefs fan and would love to see LJ do something like he did a couple years ago( 1600 yds in 9 games or something like that) but if he dont produce this year, i think his name needs to come off the roster, and go on your list of overrated players. he just signed a huge contract before last season started too.

Answer 4

eli manning he suks and gets way to much credit for winning a superbowl he got lucky as h**l

Answer 5

Tony Romo

Answer 6

Favre

When he throws an INT its the Receivers fault but when he throws a TD he is god.

All the broadcasters that love favre p**s me off!

Answer 7

Favre

Answer 8

Brett Favre and Tony Romo (tie)

Answer 9

Reggie Bush because he can't live up to the Hype.

Answer 10

1.  Brett Favre

2.  Vince Young

3.  Reggie Bush

4.  Marc Bulger

5.  Lawrence Moroney

6.  Asante Samuel

Answer 11

Vince Young.

To the person who said Peterson is overrated.. are you retarded?

EDIT: I understand what you're saying, but to call him overrated is ridiculous. Second leading rusher in the league his rookie season, even when he missed a few games. To be considered an elite back and consistent every year is one thing.. but being called overrated after what he accomplished as a rookie is another.

Answer 12

McNabb

Answer 13

I have to go with Reggie Bush on this one over Vince Young, but it is a close race between the two.  And to think, Matt Leinart is right up there.  

Answer 14

Mcnabb he's so bad i can't stand him.

Answer 15

Tony Romo is the most overrated whether your a Cowboys fan or not. He gets way too much publicity and he hasn't even won in the playoffs yet. In fact, he's the reason why the Cowboys lost the last two years in the playoffs (botched snap on a field goal, last minute interception). He hasn't stepped up to the plate in the team's most crucial situations.If he gets the team to the Superbowl (win or lose), then maybe he gets an ounce of respect from me.

Answer 16

adrian peterson i mean this guy only did what he did for a half of season he has to dominate for at least three years before i can annoint him with the top backs in the game no way should people be picking him over LT in fantasy drafts now i may eat my words but ill admit im wrong if he can do it a few seasons in arow like tomlinson,emmitt,curtis martin,barry etc...

sorry im not jumpin on someones jock cause he played for half a season lets see how he does when people have film on him and are actually game planning for him you know eight in the box like LT has seen his whole career tavarius jackson scares know one and i would rather let him try and beat me just being realistic

judging by all these thumbs down i got i think you people got it twisted i never said he sucked or wasnt good but to say hes better than LT ,Westbrook, im just saying people really do have to gameplan to stop him lets see how he does then before we say he is the best player in the NFL

Answer 17

Romo.

Answer 18

Brett Favre,no one is giving the Green Bay Packers defense any credit,everyone including the kissbutts at ESPN only give credit to Brett for the wins the Packers had last year,when it was the defense who gave the Packers the chance to win

Answer 19

Im going to go with Brett Favre

Answer 20

Well it was vick but we don't have to worry about that guy anymore.so im going to have to go with Randy Moss.

Answer 21

1.) Romo

2.) P. Manning

3.) McNabb

4.) T. Brady