Who Will Have a Better Rookie Season?

Question

Matt Forte of the Bears? or Darren McFadden of the Raiders..thats is if either start.

Answer 1

Matt Forte will rush for 683 yards on 3.4 yards per carry.

Darren McFadden will rush for 832 yards on 4.3 yard per carry.

So, McFadden.  

Answer 2

i'd rather have Mendenhall.

Answer 3

I think Matt Forte has much more to prove than McFadden.  Had Matt Forte played at Arkansas and Darren McFadden played at Tulane there is no doubt that Matt would have been more recognized for his efforts.  I suspect that McFadden will be in the media more for his off the field activities than he will for on the field.  He dislocated his big toe last year in an incident at a nightclub and I think that could be an indication of things to come.  Matt Forte reminds me of Barry Sanders.

Answer 4

i say McFadden will

Answer 5

Darren Mcfadden will snatch the starting job and run all over the competition. Sorry I am a bit biased, though.  

Answer 6

McFadden, and he won't even have to start....

Answer 7

mcfadden

i never even heard of forte

Answer 8

Darren McFadden aka Run DMC without a doubt, plus Matt Forte wont even have that good of a year the Bears have a terrible o-line and whichever RB runs there doesnt put up the great of numbers, just ask Cedric Benson or Thomas Jones

Answer 9

McFadden without a doubt.

Anyone that said Forte knows nothing about football.

Absolutely nothing.  

Check back in five months.

Answer 10

mcfadden

Answer 11

Matt forte cause oak also has bush and fargas. chi got no 1.

Answer 12

McFadden.. and he SHOULD start, if he doesn't the Raiders will then be a true and epic failure as a franchise.

Answer 13

i think forte

he has a better line

and will probably get more touches than mcfadden

and it looks like the bear running game is gonna be the better weapon on offense

Answer 14

I'm pretty sure Forte will get much more carries, Jones is not reliable and Peterson is average at best. This will probably give Forte the edge.

Answer 15

mcfadden