Who Would Rather Have At Quarterback?

Question

My friends and I were fighting about who we would rather have at quarterback: Peyton, Brady, Romo, Eli, Favre, or Roethlisberger? We all had someone different, but I chose Peyton. Who do you think?

Answer 1

I would have to agree with you that Petyon is the better QB to have.  Those names in that list are names that may one day be in the Hall of fame.  However Petyon is the one that stands out to me the most because he is a student of the game.  He is dedicated to knowing the ins and outs of football.  If you have seen him on the field when he is on the sidelines he is studying the formations and he has proven to be the type of QB that shows raw emotion.  When he misses a play its visible, when he makes a play or sees his teammates  win, he joins in.  The other QB's aren't quite the same.  Peyton stands out because he is the leader of that offense, and he knows what it takes to win in games of great importance.  Remember that game against Tampa Bay a couple of seasons ago, the game where they came back from a large deficit?  He led that team to that win.  My point is that Manning is a future hall of famer with a great arm, and a tremendous knowledge of the game..  

Answer 2

Lol Peyton

Answer 3

chad pennington

Answer 4

Peyton Manning is probably the best then tom brady.

Answer 5

peyton (im from indiana). he efficient, accurate,poise, had a record from 4 years, one a superbowl , and had enough balls to cheat on one of the hottest girr=ls ive seen in ashley manning...

Answer 6

hands down favre we had him for 16 years and was fun to watch romo is taking after him

Answer 7

Peyton easily. Brady stepped into an established team (that cheated) and did very well. Manning started with nothing and had a team built for him that is a super bowl contender every year. If brady had started out 1-15 they would have pulled the plug on him and we wouldnt ever hear his name again because of the talent around him when he started.

Answer 8

Peyton easily, brady is a cheater

Answer 9

I would rather have Tom Brady, his records speak for themselves. Of course with protection lol.  I also love Peyton, but after this season deff. Brady.  

Answer 10

Have you seen what Brady can do with 2 minutes on the clock andsome decent field position? He is one of the better comeback QBs in the league, so I would rather have him. When Peyton Broke the record he had Marvin Harrison, he is also one of those recievers that allow you to throw it up and he will probably come down with the catch. Smith and Chad can do it too. The goal is to win championships not just to have an awesome record. Brady does a better job at tha than Manning, plus he can put up stats.

Answer 11

Big Ben

Answer 12

Brady, even though he's Boston scum.

Answer 13

I think Tom Brady is the very best choice and I think if you have less than 2 minutes left on the clock and you are behind there is nobody better.  He has the rings to prove it.

Answer 14

Roethlisberger.

Answer 15

well peyton is the best all around qb out of those listed

brady-amazing in the clutch and always makes great decisions and can turn nobody wide recievers into good recievers, but he seems to crumble when under the pressure of d-linesmen

romo-horrible all around, horrible in the clutch, horrible under pressure, only good because of his star reciever, tight end, and o line

eli-hasnt really shown that he could be a good qb until the play offs, idk if thats a good thing but he did look great under the pressure and he really controlled that team, but still not that great in the normal season

favre-all around good qb except he throws too many INTs

roethisberger-well big bens really great all around but sometimes he forces the ball when he's about to be sacked and thats not good lol

peyton has seriously no flaws, good in the clutch, amazing passer, does well when a linesmen is in his face, knows how to fit the ball into places, knows how to read the defense, just alll around great qb

Answer 16

I would go Manning then Favre then Brady, if all were in their prime.

**** ROMO THE HOMO

**** ELI

**** CHEESBERGER

Answer 17

Peyton is probably the best overall Quarterback. Brady would be my second choice. Eli would be my last choice because he isn't really that good.

Answer 18

Well I would say Favre only from a biased point of view but I would take him back in his prime. But I would have to say Peyton. He is on his way to breaking some major records in his career.  

Answer 19

peyton hands down look who brady gets to throw to