Who agrees with me that no one can play Edward Cullen? He just is described as perfect.?

Question

I guess some guy from Harry Potter is supposed to play him, but he just doesn't look like he should for Edward.

We are all open to our opinions. All answers are accepted.

Answer 1

i think so too. maybe if we ripped of the good peices of our favorite celebreties and glued it all together we'd find the perfect edward. like the guy whos playing jasper's smile :] haha yeah but i think robert patterson or whatever can play him only because the more you look at him as edward, the more you can kind of see it

Answer 2

i think that Robert pattinson will do a good job. but theres really no one who can fill edwards shoes. they are just to big, is one way of putting it.

Answer 3

thats exactly what went through my head but i think he'll do a good job.

Answer 4

hahahahahaha i agree with u Robert Pattenson is not Edward material no one is really he is perfect (in looks)  

Answer 5

I agree. No one can really play Edward, but they could have found someone better for the job. Someone slightly more attractive and masculine.  

Answer 6

No,he isn't good enough to be edward,but honestly,nobody is.Edward is inhumanly perfect,so it's a tough role to fill.

still,i like who they picked as edward a lot more then i like who they picked for bella.i think he'll be fine in the movie.

Answer 7

No one can play the perfect Edward Cullen, but I thin Robert can try.

SM said that he looked like the Edward in her head so we have to hope for the best.

Rob is kind of hot 2!!!

Answer 8

YOU'RE TOTALLY RIGHT. The Rob guy is WAY too average. Sorry but Edward is supposed to be a god, and the actor portraying him looks like mere mortal, so to speak.

Answer 9

Yeah, I think any movie about someone who's supposed to be so incredibly beautiful is sort of going to disappoint in that area. Plus, I don't know if they're going to make his eyes really cool. I like who they chose for Bella though. Robert Pattinson is pretty hot though, for a human. :P

Answer 10

Yes Robert Pattinson is playing Edward Cullen. I think that his going to do a perfect job! He is so good looking. And his a very good actor. But that's just my opinion.

Answer 11

I agree 100% robert pattinson or whatever his name is wasn't what Edward is described as, he isn't masculine enough or good looking enough.

Answer 12

I think that he looks like edward a lot! Or at least how he 'should' look.

Answer 13

Robert Pattinson is a fine Edward Cullen.

The reason you feel like no one will ever be able to play him is because Stephenie Meyer is queen of implausible writing.