Question:

Who benefited more from this deal?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

http://games.espn.go.com/nba/features/traderesult?players=136~869~2986~1017&teams=18~18~17~17&te=&cash=

 Tags:

   Report

9 ANSWERS


  1. vince


  2. the nets get randoph, a c**p player who only has offense (and even then, he needs alot of touches), and renaldo baulman, who doesn't really do much.

    new york on the other hand gets vince carter, a one-man wrecking ball (on the decline in his career, but still a handful), and the expiring 3 million dollar contract of van horn.  vince carter can pull crowds easily, but honestly, new york is still screwed, although it would have a nice lineup (somewhat) of duhon, crawford, carter, lee, curry

  3. Certainly, the Knicks got the better end of this deal. They would be getting a star player in Carter, and Van Horn, a serviceable role player. Remember, Carter's numbers last season hasn't changed that much, and he could still put up amazing stats.

  4. Dunno. The Nets? And that's only because Keith Van Horn doesn't play anymore.

  5. I would have to say Knicks. They got Vince Carter, who can play the role of "leader" for the team while the Nets only got a replacement for Nachbar in the form of Randolph.

  6. that not a good deal for both. i think the knick because they would get a another big contract and lose the valuable renoldo balkman

  7. the knicks got the better end of the deal...the nets already have a lot of potential at pf with sean williams, josh boone, yi jianlian, and nenad kristic able to play both the pf or c...randolph is overrated (he totally sucks at defense, and he isn't exactly athletic)...carter is still a good player (no one is going to fill his role if he leaves)

  8. New York for sure, Randolph's contract is only 1 year shorter than VC's and Nets have a crowded frontcourt now. No way Nets will do it!(VC can sell more tickets also)

  9. Knicks. They get Vince Carter, who is a good X-FACTOR for a team in which they get rid of a scrappy guy in Ronaldo Balkman.

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 9 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Unanswered Questions