Who can sing better?

Question

Mariah Carey or Christina Aguilera.

Pick one & give your reason why.

Answer 1

I perfer Xtina style of music But I think Mariah Is a better singer

Answer 2

Christina Aguilera. I love her so much she has one of the best voices

EVER.

Answer 3

thats hard but i think mariah

Answer 4

Mariah Carey hands down is the best singer....

Answer 5

Mariah Carey!

Her voice is right at the top!

She can break windows if she wants to

Answer 6

Christina Aguilera

I like her voice better

I like Mariah's voice, but a lot of her songs have really bad lyrics that don't make sense

Answer 7

It's hard to choose. Both are AMAZING singers and both have their own distinctive voice and sound. Mariah is famous for her whistle notes, while Xtina's voice is quite powerful compared to Mariah's. And moreover, both are from different voice types, Mariah is a soprano where as Xtina is a mezzo-soprano, so it's hard to draw a comparison.

However, if you're refering to the old-days Mariah (back in her early career), then I would say Mariah. Mariah's voice has gotten worse these days although she can still sing.

Xtina on the other hand also has some nice pipes but she has a tendency to oversing and do too much melismas and improvisations it just takes the song too far away from the original form. I just wish she would just sing simpler and puts less improvisations.

Overall, I would say: BOTH. Coz they both have their share of strength and weaknesses. And I don't think it's right to compare singers of their calibre to each other. They both are great singers, we all know that, so we should more celebrate their talent and the art they provided to us instead of trying to creat an unnecessary "competition" here.

Answer 8

christina aguilera, she can hit her notes perfectly and has such a stunning voice.

mariah carey, is ear shattering. plus she acts like she's all that....blah...

Answer 9

Christina now...Mariah has sold out and her stuff isnt like it used to be. She can hit some high notes but Christina has the power!

Answer 10

I prefer Christina.

I really like her music.

I only like one of Mariah's song and thats when David Cook is singing that version of it.  

Answer 11

I like both of them.