Who do I keep? Willie Parker or Michael Turner?

Question

I am in a small 8 team keeper league. i am sure on most my keepers, but I need to keep either Parker or Turner. Both are going to have to share carries this year. Parker had a bad season last year with his lack of consistency and Turner was a backup behind a great O line. So i'm stuck. What do you think?

Answer 1

Keep Parker.

He is the proven starter who has put up numbers each season.

Michael Turner has never proven that he is a great starter.  He has played backup his whole career.  Not to mention the fact that the Falcons already have a talented young back in Jerious Norwood.  Turner is talented sure, but honestly i don't know why everyone thinks he will be so amazing.  I think most of his productivity in San Diego was due to the fact that defenses relaxed once LT was taken off the field. That's just my opinion, but i'd definitely keep Parker.

Answer 2

Michael Turner may get 300 touches under new(run orientated)O'coordinator Mike Malarki this year.(BTW-

Roddy Whites'(WR) touches will go down.)

Parkers' workload will greatly decrease with the addition of 1st round pick R.Mendenhall in the fold....(I'd deffinately keep

Turner.)~~G{}{}d Luck!

Answer 3

Keep Turner he will have a breakout year, parker will not.

Answer 4

Id keep Parker and Drop turner then pick up mendenhall

Answer 5

Keep Turner, Trade Parker. Don't  get rid of him just like that!  At least get a draft pick for him