Who do I keep in my fantasy football keeper league?

Question

I have a bunch of potential keepers for my football league this season. I have to keep 2. Here are the players and the breakdown of league

Starters

QB - 1

RB - 2

WR - 2

TE - 1

K - 1

DEF - 1

20 Pass yds - 1pt

Pass INT - -2 pts

10 Receiving yds - 1pt

10 Rushing yds - 1pt

All 2pt conversions - 2pts

All TDs - 6pts

Plays of 20 yds or more - 1pt

Plays of 40 yds or more - 1pt

QB - Carson Palmer

RB - Ryan Grant

RB - Willis McGahee

WR - Braylon Edwards

WR - Larry Fitzgerald

WR - Wes Welker

WR - Marvin Harrison

WR - Donald Driver

I need to keep TWO! What do you think?

Answer 1

I would keep Edwards and Grant if it were me.  McGahee would be a decent option but I think Grant will be better over the long haul - maybe this year also.  No Palmer.  And I would say Edwards over Fitz, the others are not even close.  Edwards has a better QB and a more balanced offense.

Answer 2

i would say wes welker (as tom brady as the QB, his fantasy numbers will be one of the tops in the league) and carson plamer cuz u need a QB and w/ chad johnson and t.j., his numbers should blossom.

Answer 3

Carson Palmer and Willis McGahee, no doubt about it.

Answer 4

I would keep Braylon Edawards for sure. Great situation and he's a stud for production although the browns now have stallworth...after that, if you want another WR go with fitzgerald. his situation should improve as the cardinals need to commit to leinart to figure out if he's the future. I would probably pick Carson Palmer. He's a strong player and valuable at QB.

Answer 5

Grant and Edwards without a doubt! Although you couldn't go wrong with Grant and Mcgahee. Id ask around to see who's keeping who if it sounds like theres allot of protected RBs you may consider keeping two backs ....but in my own opinion i couldn't let Edwards go.

Answer 6

This scoring definitely favors QB's and you got a top 5 fantasy QB in Palmer, keep him.  As for your other keeper, i would say Ryan Grant.  Everyone goes crazy for RB's in the draft and you would regret not keeping at least one prior to the draft, especially one with top 10 potential like Grant.  McGahee just lost his franchise left tackle to retirement and they are likely to start a rookie QB while Grant has the benefit of a better oline, a QB with at least a little game experience (Rodgers) or possibly the return of Favre.  You can always get one of those WR's back in the draft.  Welker gets a ton of catches but none for huge gains, Fitz is only a red zone WR, and who knows if the Browns will continue offensively where they left off last year.