Who do u believe would be in better shape?

Question

A top shape marine Or somebody like Floyd Mayweather.

Answer 1

Floyd would be in better physical shape. A marine is in top shape but not in boxing shape especially floyd maywether shape. The marine might have the mental advantage but not the physical advantage.

Answer 2

A Boxer is in absoulute Shape but when you tallk about a top shape marine the marine is going to be in better shape. I meanwere not talking about punches right were talking about health.

A boxer trains trains to be able to dodge move and throw punches for twelve rounds and its not like Mayweather keeps active all twelve rounds for every second. I mean i dont think he can run a marathin or any thing like that.

Put them both in a triatholon and i put my money on the marine.

Answer 3

Mayweather practically runs a marathon every day for his training.  Boxers are the best conditioned athletes in the world.  There is not one big name boxer who doesn't run at least ten miles at a time on a regular basis.  If you think that three minute rounds of throwing punches, being punched, and constantly moving is not a long time you have obviously never stepped in the ring.  It is asinine to say that a marine is in better shape than a boxer.  Floyd Mayweather may be the best conditioned athlete in the world.  Make no mistake.  I have no love for Mayweather, but lots of respect (for his physical work, not for him making an idiot of himself).

Answer 4

Floyd Mayweather,Shane Mosley either one would be in better shape then most top shape marines.

Most  Boxers in the lower weight classes are the most finally conditioned athletes in the world

Lester guy down there, Hes not asking who is better at their game, hes asking who is in better physical shape.

If you put Floyd Mayweather or Shane Mosley in a fitness test against a marine i guarantee you they would be in better shape.

and yes their fights are 3 minute rounds 1 minute breaks, but in training they can box for up to 45 minutes or longer without a break, they don't take breaks until they absolutely cant go anymore.

Theres no athletes in better shape then top pro boxers, especially at the lower weight class's.

I know a few marines and they are not in that great a shape at all. Now if your talking Navy Seals, well those guys wouldn't be as in physically top shape as Mosley or Mayweather. They train there bodies to withstand extreme conditions..that's not necessarily top physical shape thats body tampering and over a long time will actually take its tole on their bodies.

Answer 5

You are comparing different types of conditioning. Boxers fight for 3 minutes and then rest for 1 minute.

They can do this for a very long time.

If a marine is fighting he does not get a rest period.

He fights until either he or his opponent is dead.

In the field he must go for days without rest and sleep.

So the boxer is better at his game and the marine is better at his.