Who do you think had the better draft, who has the better deam?

Question

TEAM A

QB 1 (#2) Brady, Tom (QB NE)

RB 2 (#19) Portis, Clinton (RB WAS)

RB 3 (#22) Johnson, Rudi (RB CIN)

WR 4 (#39) Williams, Roy (WR DET)

WR 6 (#59) Ward, Hines (WR PIT)

WR 8 (#79) Chambers, Chris (WR SD)

TE 9 (#82) Davis, Vernon (TE SF)

K 14 (#139) Rackers, Neil (K ARI)

DST 12 (#119) Jaguars, DST (DST JAC)

RS 11 (#102) Kitna, Jon (QB DET)

RS 5 (#42) Parker, Willie (RB PIT)

RS 7 (#62) Jacobs, Brandon (RB NYG)

RS 10 (#99) Curtis, Kevin (WR PHI)

RS 13 (#122) Cowboys, DST (DST)

TEAM B

QB 5 (#45) McNabb, Donovan (QB PHI)

RB 1 (#5) Jackson, Steven (RB STL)

RB 2 (#16) Barber, Marion (RB DAL)

WR 3 (#25) Johnson, Andre (WR HOU)

WR 4 (#36) Johnson, Chad (WR CIN)

WR 8 (#76) Evans, Lee (WR BUF)

TE 6 (#56) Shockey, Jeremy (TE NO)

K 9 (#85) Vinatieri, Adam (K IND)

DST 7 (#65) Bears, DST (DST CHI)

RS 10 (#96) Rodgers, Aaron (QB GB)

RS 11 (#105) Forte, Matt (RB CHI)

RS 12 (#116) Rice, Sidney (WR MIN)

RS 13 (#125) Olsen, Greg (TE CHI)

RS 14 (#136) Browns, DST (DST CLE)

Answer 1

QB - Brady is the best, hands down. McNabb is a top 5 QB when he is healthy, but not near the level Brady is.

Team B has the better backup with Rodgers.

Brady wins that catagory for team A.

RB - Portis has been up and down, but the Redskins have made a few changes offensively to help him excell. Rudi Johnson is on a mission to come back as good as he was before, and I believe he will. Willie Parker may not get the TDs, but he racks up yards, and that gets you points. Jacobs will plow through defenses just like last season as well.

Steven Jackson is in a contract dispute with the Rams,and may miss all of training camp or more. Barber is an animal, he will produce good numbers for team B. As far as Forte goes, it's a mistery. The RB situation in Chicago is a mess. Everyone is jumping on the Forte badwagon, but there is "the other" Adrian Peterson to take into account as well. I don't see much production from Forte.

I have to give team A the RB catagory as well.

WR - Ward has been a disappointment for a couple years now. He is getting older and I am afraid his point production for fantasy football has faded away. Roy Williams is probably the best WR on the Lions, but how much that is worth remains to be seen. He will get some good stats for team A since Kitna looks for him first. Chris Chambers will be the best WR for the Chargers, but they have a run oriented offense.

Curtis had 1,000 yds last season, but just under half of that was in 3 games. The other 13 games he wasn't worthy of even having on a roster.

Andre Johnson is an awsome deep ball WR. He racks up yds and TDs when he is healthy. Chad Johnson may be a big whiner, but he is consistant. He will get his yards and TDs like he does every year. Lee Evans is the go to WR in Buffalo, but that offense is weak. S. Rice is a gamble. He may break out, but I doubt it. Not worth much.

Despite Rice, I give the WR edge to team B.

TE - Vernon Davis is going to be a big part of the 49er offense this year. He had an injury last season that kept him from being one of the better TE int he league.

Shockey not only brings his ability to New Orleans, but he brings his big mouth and attitude with him. He will excel for this season, but next season he will be just as big a pain in the butt for the Saints as he was for the Giants.

Olsen is a solid back up at TE. Not spectacular by any means, but he won't hurt you more than help you.

TE goes to team B.(basically based on V. Davis ability to come back from injury)

DEF - Jags have put together a solid dependable defense and have a very defense oriented coach. They will be one of the best. Cowbosy as well will be a top 5 defense this season.

Bears defense is getting old and they will struggle because the offense is so bad the defense will have to be on the field most of the game.They are not the "mosters of the midway" as they once were.Plus they have had plenty of distractions this summer.

Browns defense is not worthy of a roster spot right now. Who knows, maybe during the offseason they did something to improve, but until they show that, dump them.

Team A wins DEF.

Based on all of that, I give it to team A over all.

Answer 2

both teams are close but i will give a slight edge to to team (a) becaue the back- up players are better.

Answer 3

Team A because they have brady and better bench players

Answer 4

I'd have to say team B. They have the better backs, Andre Johnson is an animal, and with those three making up points for the Brady Mcnabb discrepency, I'd look for the second team listed to be the better of the two this year.

Answer 5

team A should be starting  brandon jacobs over rudi johnson.   should have avoided willie '2 tds" parker.   i personally dont like drafting 2 defenses  why do it?   you can pick up one for the bye week  easily.  you could load up on an extra wr or rb

the bench on team b is weak.  and the starters have some questions  can mcnabb, jackson, stay healthy  will chad johson play or pout,  shockey is a great pick at te.  he will be brees fav  security blanket.  brees does not have a super strong arm  and the saints have never had a good te.  Again why 2 defenses?  and especially why the browns??  they are terrible ondefense   they improved the D-line  but their secondary was weaker  and they lost their best db from last year!!

team b is better  at rb, wr, and te

team a is better at QB, and the defenses are even

team b is better overall

Answer 6

I'm gonna go out on a limb and say B.