Who do you think is a better baseball player, Josh Hamilton or Alex Rodriguez

Question

Who do you think is a better baseball player, Josh Hamilton or Alex Rodriguez

Answer 1

They are two of the most talented players in the game but I would say Alex Rodriguez. He's done it for a much longer time and plays a more challenging defensive position.

Answer 2

Alex Rodriguez has proven that he is a great baseball player.

Josh Hamilton is having a breakout year.

Answer 3

Josh Hamilton

www.sportsfanboards.com

Answer 4

definitley arod because he has proven himself over the years. Hey 2 years ago Josh Hamilton was playing A ball so he has to keep it up for at least another 5 years until I can say he is better. Anyways this year I think Arod is better. He would have had amazing numbers by now if he didn't have that injury

Answer 5

While I love Hamilton's story, he's going to need a few years of sustained production for this question to be relevant.

Answer 6

a-rod  

Answer 7

At this point, A-Rod is the best player in the game. Hamilton is having a breakout season after overcoming his past problems; he is quickly establishing himself as one of the game's most feared hitters.

Answer 8

A Rod cause he has put up great numbers his whole career & Josh Hamilton is having a breakthrough year.  I am interested in what Hamilton does the next couple of years though

Answer 9

A-Rod is a better overall player when looking at all 5 tools, but Hamilton looks better offensively this year.

Answer 10

Arod for now,but in a few years it may be hamilton.