Who do you think is the most under achieving team in the AFL?

Question

Even I must say it is Collingwood. We have the most money. We try to buy the best coaches though I dont think Malthouse has what it takes. McKenna was sacked from the Eagles before we took him. We are supposed to have the best facilities but we have won one premiership in about the past 60 years or so. We get hand me down players from other clubs. I think we need a cleanout at the club and start afresh.

Answer 1

Richmond, They have not been in the top 8 in like a long time.

Answer 2

Hawthorn!!!

Answer 3

What do you mean by "We" Collingwood "?They ain't owned by "We" person, yet.

Start afresh ? how do "We" do that. ?

At any rate,  the best facilities does not make a footy club.

You're right about Malthouse, he is the same as Sheedy, old blokes hanging around far too long, and making a nuisance of themselves. Eddie feels a sense of loyalty to Malthouse and wouldn't "Bone him"

Answer 4

Melbourne.

Answer 5

I'm sad to say its my beloved Saints. On paper and excluding injuries, we've had one of the best sides in the comp for the last 5 years, but still can't even deliver a grand final appearance let alone a premiership!

Go Saints for 2008!!!!

Answer 6

What constitutes 'under-achieving' ??

I don't think I can pick a team, they all have their faults, including Collingwood (they are not consistent with their game).  The only team I cannot fault is Geelong - they were superstars this year.

Answer 7

the saints suck, i wish they woulda left like they were gonna

Answer 8

geelong- they havent won a grand final for 2 1/2 months.

Answer 9

The Roos

Answer 10

Richmond is under achieving

Answer 11

In the past few years it would be St. Kilda as they had the list but couldn't convert it on the field to a premiership.

They still have a good list and who knows they might just make me eat my words

Answer 12

If you're talking Premierships, which I guess is the only real success, then yeah Collingwood & Saints, also Dogs.

If you're talking finals appearances, then over the last 20 years Richmond & Freo.