Who do you think is the most under rated player in the AFL?

Question

Who do you think is the most under rated player in the AFL?

Answer 1

I think Robert Harvey. When we talk about the best players of his era, we mention hird, voss, buckley, carey. Harvey won back to back brownlow medals and has been amazingly consistent. No one talks about him because st. kilda are not a very successful team.

Answer 2

Alan Didak... and Leon Davis

Answer 3

good question richo and hard to answer,for me id go with-scott west,hes an absolute champion but doesn't quite get the accolades he deserves.

Jarrod Waite-,big, athletic like a spider,can play up forward and be a real marking and goal kicking option or down back where he can take on the best forward the opposition has (like the job he did on reiwaldt the other week-smashed him)

Paul Chapman-ultra consistent and just a dangerous player that flies under the radar,haven't seen him play a bad game and he always smashes us (the blues) when we've played them.

Answer 4

In my opinion Cameron Bruce, ........I think mainly because the Demons, are in a way, unfashionable ...trying to think what it is about them ..but they dont seem to attrack media attention like other clubs ..but Bruce is always up there among the elite and without much fanfare .. Scott West is  another always up with the leaders and has been close on several occassions to Brownlow glory, and  is consistently very competitive,  but  again without much fanfare from the media .

Answer 5

Tarkyn Lockyer. He is an extremely consistent and versatile player. He racks up at least 15 disposals per game and the Press has never given him the credit. His injury in 2003 really hampered his progress and if it hadn't been for that injury he would be up there with Cousins and Judd as the best players in the game.

Answer 6

Peter Everitt.

Answer 7

Cameron Ling & Paul Chapman - both excellent & under rated

Answer 8

I think Brodie Holland is the most under rated player

Answer 9

Matthew lappin always plays a cracker every week for the blues

Answer 10

Paul Chapman/ Scott West

Answer 11

David Wirrapanda he just turns up every week does the job and gets lost amongst all the other star players and doesn't get the recognition he deserves.