Who do you think the top 5 active players in the mlb are?

Question

My List:

1. Albert Pujols

2. Alex Rodriguez

3. Matt Holiday

4. Ryan Braun

5. Josh Hamilton

Answer 1

I don't know if you mean recent history or just this year, but here's my list:

1. Alex Rodriguez

2. Albert Pujols

3. Hanley Ramirez

4. Johan Santana

5. David Wright

Answer 2

Right now..

1. Alex Rodriguez

2. Francisco Rodriguez

3. Josh Hamilton

4. Chase Utley

5. Albert Pujois

Answer 3

The top 5 active players in terms of All-Time???

1. Griffey

2. A-Rod

3. R. Johnson

4. M. Ramirez

5. Smoltz

Answer 4

I like your top 2, but your bottom 3 haven't been playing long enough to put on this list and Holliday shouldn't even be a thought here.  I'm rather surprise so many people have Holliday on their list.  Take this guy out of Coors Field and he's mediocre at best.

1. Alex Rodriguez

2. Albert Pujols

3. Vlad Guerrero

4. Chase Utley

5. Aramis Ramirez

Answer 5

1. Matt Holliday

2. Albert Pujols

3. Chase Ultley

4. A-Rod

5. Josh Hamilton

Answer 6

Where are your pitchers?

I would rather have Roy Halladay, Brandon Webb, Carlos Zambrano, or John Lackey over Ryan Braun.  

Braun has a great bat, but he is a huge liability in the field, keeping him from making my top 5.

I would say:

1) Alex Rodriguez

2) Hanley Ramirez

3) Albert Pujols

4)  Roy Halladay

5) Carlos Zambrano

Honorable Mention - Rich Harden if he can stay healthy for an entire season.

Answer 7

A rod

Pujols

Matt Holliday

Carlos Zambrano

Brandon Webb

  

Answer 8

1. josh hamilton

2. prince fielder

3. ryan braun

4. cc sabathia

5. jj hardy

Answer 9

All around? Hitters? Pitchers? Relief? Closing?

Your list is just hitters. If that is what you mean you are close but you got to change around 1 & 2. A-Rod is called "the greatest player on the planet" becasue he is 2nd best? He will break the HR record & probably many other. Pujols is good but not legendary!

Answer 10

1.Josh Hamilton

2.Dustin Pedroia

3.Alex Rodriguez

4.Vladimir Guerrero

5.Prince Fielder  

Answer 11

Lance Berkman

Ian Kinsler

Jose Reyes

Matt Holliday

Josh Hamilton