Who does Allah like more: Saddam Hussein, or Ghandi?

Question

Saddam said shahada as his last words. Ghandi didn't.

Answer 1

Thanks. I was about to post a similar question. This perfect deity's obsession with his worship leads him to make such an insane judgment. I suspect he's suffering from COD.

May his creator guide him.

Answer 2

Only Allah swt knows. You can not get a right answer becasue the people answering dont know Allah's thought.

Answer 3

Atleast Saddam is a Muslim !!!!!!!!!!

Only Allah knows the truth about Him  ???????

Gandi is in h**l with his weel and Lungi/Dhothi !!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 4

Allah treats everyone at the same level.

Answer 5

I think its Saddam.

Ghandi is a Mushrik.

Edit

I dont know if Allah will grant Saddam heaven or not. But from the Quran we know, Allah forgives any sin EXCEPT Shirk. But sadly the modernist Muslims will ignore this fact.

Answer 6

He loved them both. He gave them life to live, and a freedom of choice.

Answer 7

Very interesting question.

If your question happened to be something like this, "Who does George Bush likes more Gordon Brown or Ho Chi Minh"?

What you would do to find the answer. You will ask George Bush. Right.

If your question about Saddam Hussein and Ghandi has become so critical to your faith that you must know the answer then would it not be a good idea to ask Allah or God?

Answer 8

All saddam did was massacre people, but ghandi being a hindu was a way better person than saddam....however, saddam did believe in Allah, while ghandi didn't, so both have a pretty close competition, which Allah must have surely decided for both of them.

Since saddam was a murderer more than being a dictator for 30+ yrs, his place is surely the fire of h**l.

Answer 9

Only Allah know.. :)

Answer 10

saying shahada doesn't absolve him of his many crimes. bad muslims go to h**l too

the pharoah and qarun also said the shahada right before they died but allah didnt accept their repentance since they had been ample opportunity to stop their arrogant actions yet they didnt while they were powerful

Answer 11

Even though I admire and love Ghandiji, he is a idol worshipper and a shirk at heart, he may go to h**l, but his punishment was that he got shot and could mean he served his punishment...but he said "oh Rama" with his last breath, and put partners with Allah.

Saddam Hussein was a Muslim by birth, but not a very good one, but he uttered the Islamic Testification of faith with his last breath, and his punishment for the ills he caused people is that he got hung, and could mean he received his punishment.

But Allah his Wise and swift in Judgement, and it lies with Him really.

Answer 12

Allah only knows

Answer 13

Gandhi good. Saddam bad. simple.

Answer 14

Why dont you go and ask him?

Answer 15

Ghandi was good

Saddam killed millions... he's in h**l

Answer 16

A silly question.

Answer 17

I think you can answer your own question.  Just because someone utters a phrase recognizing the oneness of God and Allah as his prophet doesn't make him a good person or a good Muslim.  Ghandi was a just and wise man who encouraged people to do what was right and just.  Sadam was a bully, greedy and only looking out for his own gain.

Answer 18

It seems to me that ur Highness is not content with fabricating 'whole brand new approaches' in religion. Is this another example of ur ' Quran-alone with an Ahmadiyya interpretation', as u stated it? Or r u going to be just another prophet?

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

I can guess why r u rotting with curiosity to work out whether Saddam or Gandhi might go to h**l or heaven. Bad news!  Have a look at this: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

I suppose this will give u a ready made excuse to launch ur prophethood? But u're not even as shrewd as the hypochondriac Mirza Qadyani character! At least he knew something of Arabic  to be able to trump up all those hazy spiritual metaphors, while it is definitely not ur forte, and it might be a great setback to ur mission, if u intend to, perhaps, concocte the desired meanings which confirm to ur whims, from the Quran.

Answer 19

There is no repentance for people who persist in doing evil until death comes to them and who then say, "Now I repent," nor for people who die rejecting Faith. We have prepared for them a painful punishment. (Qur'an 4: 17-18)

Answer 20

none. Allah loves those who is Muhibb of his Ahlubait(a.s)

and follow ther teachings ..and none of them did

Answer 21

no comparison!

Answer 22

Saddam is Muslim, but  Ghandi is not!!

now you tell me who?

Answer 23

How can we tell

Answer 24

in the eyes of allah only allah knows.why take only saddam as the representation of a whole muslim people,read the life the mohammed peace be upon him,his companion ,the saint of islam,read what they done,read the progress of the muslim in science,medicine,why put hate in the heart of others ,why put these disease out,we are not happy at least respect others,its the less of good,muslim pray the creator of all things,others pray creation of god,we respect,mohammed himself deal with none muslim  ,surely he has done a lot of bad thing, and certainly he will be judge.how do we know that ghandi did not say shahada..

Answer 25

hold on. wait untill we reach there.

2:256. La ikraha fee alddeeni qad tabayyana alrrushdu mina alghayyi faman yakfur bialttaghooti wayu/min biAllahi faqadi istamsaka bialAAurwati alwuthqa la infisama laha waAllahu sameeAAun AAaleemun

Answer 26

Its a very common hadit that the prophet Muhammad(PBUH) said that some people in the whole life move along the door of heaven and at the end go to h**l,and some people move along the door of h**l and at  the end go to heaven,

Saddam Was martyred and gave his life bravely in from of Americans

Answer 27

I do not know about you but I usually ask the source of the question what did Allah say?my understanding of my God is He loves all of his children the good and bad

Answer 28

Gandhi!!!

Saddam didnt say it like he meant it......He never believed in Allah and he didnt even when he died.......He didnt say Shahadah from his heart, he said it from his mouth

Saddam did it to stir up some popularity.......he wanted to have some kind of dignity after acknowledging defeat. He was one of the major secularist leaders of the 20th century. Saddam wanted to have a sort of legacy after his death

p.s. its GANDHI NOT GHANDI...... that is a typical American spelling mistake.

plus only Allah knows who He will like more... Logic says its Gandhi the simple and noble Indian who respected all