Who else hopes Judd ends up at Richmond?

Question

No contract has been signed, no deal has been done and it looks like it wont happen anytime soon...!

*FINGERS CROSSED* the deal falls through and Judd is drafted to Richmond and WC Eagles get NOTHING!!

PS: As a Pies supporter, I am so relieved that Judd picked Carlton...!!

Answer 1

ITS A DONE DEAL,there's absolutely no chance west coast will let the arguably best player of a decade go for nothing,could you imagine being the person at west coast that let that happen-you'd be hounded out of the state,when push comes to shove picks 3,20 and josh Kennedy is a far better result that 0/nothing,

also why wouldn't you want him at collingwood? if you didn't have to give away some of the young kids,he'd increase membership,merchandise sales and create alot more interest in your club,and they think he'll basically pay for his first year of his contract in these things and not to mention add another dimension to your midfield-please explain

Answer 2

i think both clubs will be looking to get that trade out of the way and could happen as soon as tomorrow,  i dont see judd going anywhere but carlton

Answer 3

Judd will go to carlton, richmond has no chance, carlton has good picks

Answer 4

Who really cares where he goes. He wont do anywhere near as good, wherever he goes, because he wont have the WCE midfielders protecting, feeding him & carrying him through a game.

I don't think he is feminine enough even to consider Collingwood.

Answer 5

OH MAN!!!!

I'd love Richmond to get him.

Richmond need something to boost them and hopefully Judd will do that,well thats if he ends up there.

I have a soft spot for the Tigers.

Answer 6

Agree with Forky

The Blues will get Judd, i would love to see him at the Tigers, but a deal must be done. WCE wont get a low pick for a long time.

A weird thing I have noticed, the recruiting officers of most clubs say they would love to have Judd If they could. Ask the average punter on the street, and they dont want to touch him! I think he is worth the risk (groin) for sure.

Answer 7

I'm a little confused at it all :)

Answer 8

I could only hope!  I love the Cats but I have a soft spot for my birth place (Richmond) and the colours I played in much of my career (and no, I didn't "play for Collingwood son" - love that ad!).

I think he'd probably do better at Tigerland too.  They have good attitude.

Edit: but sadly Forky's probably right.  I hate that :-)