Who gets the Better Fantasy Baseball Trade?

Question

I get Chase Utley

He gets Josh Hamilton

My other outfielders are Matt Kemp, Ryan Ludwick, Milton Bradley, Nick Markakis, Matt Holliday and Ryan Church.

My current second baseman is Placido Polanco and I have Chone Figgins on the DL

Answer 1

Yeah, i agree with the guy above me. Hamilton is unproven and will cool off in the second half, although I think he'll still drive in more than 100 runs and hit 32-41 homers by season's end. Utley, on the other hand, is proven, smacking homers last year and drivin in runs while fielding great. You get the better side of the trade.

Answer 2

You do, Utley is the best fantasy player this year. Hamilton will slightly cool off in the second half. Utley is much better though because of the thin position he plays. You have 3 solid outfielders in Bradley, Markakis, and Holliday so you could afford to lose Hamilton.

Answer 3

Utley is having a MVP year , Hamilton is knocking the snot out of the ball. You are set in the outfield and need a 2nd baseman. Do it you will be happy. Good Luck!