Who gets the better end of the deal

Question

CC Sabathia for Jason Bay

Answer 1

Sabathia has been absolutely tearing up NL lineups. You could get a much better player for sabathia. I would be willing to give up players like Ryan Braun or David Wright to get him.  

Answer 2

It really depends on each team's needs, but performance-wise, I'd say Sabathia, since awesome starters are harder to come by than Power OFs.

Bay is going to produce a good amount in a potent Bahstun line-up, but Sabathia has been lights-out of late, and is in the midst of a playoff race, so he'll be needed to continue his outstanding pitching.

In conclusion, whoever receives Sabathia is the clear-cut winner.

Answer 3

Ryan Braun for CC Sabathia!? That's what the other guy said, that's ridiculous, you can't do that. But, I'd say the person getting CC in your deal is getting the better deal. But it really depends on team needs, if you are lacking strikeouts, CC would be a huge pickup, if you want too add a power bat to your team, Jason Bay would be a big pickup.  

Answer 4

The team getting CC because he is undefeated for the brewers.