Who gets the better end of the fantasy football trade?

Question

side A gets kellen winslow

plaxico burress

jamal lewis

side B gets tony gonzalez

andre johnson

clinton portis

Answer 1

B

Andre and tony are steals

A isn't because Kellen is good and young

plexico gets to much credit he really is not that good he's just tall

Clinton is injured to much

Answer 2

man it looks too me that trade is about even but who ever gets clinton portis wins the trade which is side B.

Answer 3

tough call, but I have to go with side A. I think Winslow is better than Gonzalez. Johnson is better than Burress I think but I feel Jamal Lewis will find the endzone more than Portis who is injury prone

Answer 4

this trade is pretty well split down the middle.  i would give a slight advantage to side B.  They lose a little at the tight end spot but with winslow's injury history who knows.  they gain it back with the wr spot.  the rb's are close but i'll give the edge to portis since he's now 2 yrs removed from his acl injury

Answer 5

Here's the overall rankings in standard format from footballguys.com:

Side A

Winslow - #54

Burress - #33 *

Lewis - #21

Side B

Gonzo -#52

Johnson - #24

Portis - #8

In all it's a very balanced trade.  So balanced, I'm not really sure that it improves one team over the other appreciably.

* The Burress ranking suggests both his past ankle problems, and his unhappiness with his contract.  I would normally rank him over Johnson, because he is a huge red zone target.

Off hand, considering age and contract issues, Side B has a narrow advantage.

Answer 6

A wins TE, B wins WR, and RB is a tossup.  I'd say that's a huge trade that is about even.  If I were picking, I would go with what A is getting, because I think Lewis will do better than Portis and I'm not totally sold on Andre Johnson.

Answer 7

pretty close, but B is a tad better imo

a)winslow>gonzalez

b)johnson>burress

b)portis>old lewis