Who gets the better end of this deal?

Question

Team A or Team B and why?

Team A gets: Troy Glaus, Vladimir Guerrero, and Alfonso Soriano

Team B gets: Carlos Guillen, Manny Ramirez, and Matt Kemp

Answer 1

Watching Manny Ramirez play every day, hes not the same Manny, hes lost a lot of bat speed.  Id take team A, I think Soriano is in for a huge 2nd half

Answer 2

team B gets the better end of it carlos is better than troy and manny in my opinion is better than vlad also manny is gitting out of his slump. Plus soriano is bound to git injured again and it wouldnt be worth the risk

Answer 3

team a

when soriano comes back he will put up numbers and you know vlad is gonna be good.

Manny is stuggling i have never been big on kemp and i dont hink guillen can keep up his all star performance.

Answer 4

I lean team A but not by much.

Answer 5

B.

Glaus never impressed me.  Manny will put up numbers.  Kemp is steady.

Answer 6

team b

Answer 7

Team A

Answer 8

team a because glos is hot with vlad and soriano and kemp and manny are cold so team a will produce more numbers good luck

Answer 9

Team B Guillen will give you more rbis and runs than glaus plus the eligibility is a nice bonus

I take Manny over Vlad here h**l get more Hrs, same amount of rbis, more runs but less avg but kemp and guillen make that up in the deal.

Soriano is flat out better than Kemp but Soriano is more of an injury risk and idk how hes gonna be with that hand

Overall Team B get the better deal