Who got the better of this deal?

Question

On April 18, I made this trade:

I gave up Carlos Pena, Ryan Zimmerman, Vladimir Guerrero, Joe Borowski, B.J. Ryan, and Roy Halladay.

I got Fyan Howard, Hank Blalock, Alfonso Soriano, Chie-Ming Wang, Jonahtan Papelbon, and Ted Lilly

Who do you feel got the better of this trade throughout the entire year. Recently, I've been affected by the injury bug (Soriano and Wang) but please keep in mind the WHOLE year so far and how each has played.

Answer 1

I'd say you got the better deal, Cubs are flying high right now, and the Jays are slumping bigtime. Your other players will probably have better years than the ones you gave up.

Answer 2

the other guy only because of the injuries you mentioned and they'll be out for a while, if that weren't the case, i think it's a fairly even trade, but soriano is way overrated in my opinion

Answer 3

he got the better deal