Who has a better shot at the NL Cy Young?

Question

Tim Lincecum 12-3 2.67 ERA 182 K

or

Brandon Webb 17-4 2.88 ERA 139 K

or

Other (If so who? And please give stats)

Answer 1

Brandon Webb 17-4 2.88 ERA 139 K

&

the d-backs are going to the playoffs where he will get some Cy-young hype and most likely he might get it .....

Answer 2

I'd love to see Lincecum,but the voters always seem to look at wins and Webb will have him there,so he'll prolly win it.

Answer 3

Brandon Webb.  Cy Young selectors always lean towards the man with the most wins it seem slike.  Webb havent had a bad year either.  BUt theres no chance TIm Linecum wins this, unfortunately for the kid.

Answer 4

i would say Edison Volquez with a ERA of  2.86(lower than webbs) and 146 K's(more K than Webb) but he also has 144IP with is 18 less innings pitched than Lincecum and 25 less IP than Webb  so its kinda hard to pick

Answer 5

could be Dan Haren 12-6 154 K  

Answer 6

I'd choose Lincecum, lower ERA and more K's. Not much a pitcher can do about wins. If the White Sox or Yanks would have traded for him when they had the chance, he'd be a no brainer...

Answer 7

      

            C.C. Sabathia 13-8  3.04 ERA 183 K

Answer 8

Brandon Webb and hey maybe even CC Sabathia!!

Answer 9

i say tim Lincecum

Answer 10

It's going to be tough, but i'll pick Brandon Webb. ERA's are close, but Lincecum has more K's.  The deciding factor in the end might be the fact that Webb pitches for a winning team and will get 20+ wins, and also Webb has more complete Games (3 vs. TL's 0) and shut outs (1 vs. TL's 0) than Lincecum.  

Answer 11

Webb has a better winning percentage, and has mroe wins, I think it should go to Lincecum but it will go to Webb

Answer 12

Brandon Webb is my selection but CC Sabathia has a good shot

For Sabathia's Stats go to http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/players/6603

Answer 13

It is def. between those 2, no arguements there.

If I had to pick one, it would probably be Webby only because he has more wins.