Who has a overall more successful career?Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?Who is better now?

Question

Who has a overall more successful career?Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?Who is better now?

Answer 1

I'll be willing to give them a serious comparison as soon as the Pats stop cheating on the sideline and pay the due price for all the cheating they have done. Until then I refuse to compare one of the best quarterbacks of the modern era with a little weasel who piled up yardage and collected Super Bowl rings by cheating.  

Answer 2

Manning I think has more skill, but Tom Brady is way more successful.

Answer 3

This question should only be answered by an objective third party. So, I'll volunteer. They BOTH have had successful careers, they'll BOTH be in the HOF and at this particular moment (3:51 pm on Saturday, August 9th) Brady is better now. Only because Manning is recovering from knee surgery.  

Answer 4

Right now Tom Brady but overall Peyton Manning but i think Tom has a chance to be just as good now that he actually has a good receiving core for 2 straight years.

Answer 5

you have to say brady simply because of how many rings he has but i like manning better

Answer 6

it's pretty obvious that it is Tom Brady!!!

Answer 7

Hard question

Tom Brady never had a good WR to throw to and still found a way to win a bunch of SB but had a 5 star team behind him

Manning had a superpowered offense yet a lackluster D that couldn't get him over the hump until now

I'd have to say that Brady is better, but he also is a jerk and a 3 star word that you cant say on Yanswers.

Succesful-Brady has more rings, Manning has a better figure in the publics eye and great all around stats

Better now is Brady but he is a little younger too

Answer 8

Brady had his best season when they're offensive line was the best of all time. He had arguably the best receiving group of all time and a h**l of a defense. So it all came together for him. People say give Brady some receivers and look what he can do. Well, first his number one receiver was already a hall of famer. People also didn't expect the offense to produce those numbers so they had no plan for them until late in the season. People expected Manning to do what he does from day one and he still produces 4000 yard season with 30tds every year. He made Harrison and Wayne both when they were rookies. He put them in the top 10. Brady didn't put Moss in the top ten, he was already sick. As a great qb, it must all come together from the line. Manning has more skill, and is better now and will play longer. Rings mean everything to a team, but they're not a personal achievement.

Answer 9

I don't know how anyone can say that Manning is more successful. Tom Brady has 3 Super Bowl rings. Manning has one. It's obvious who is more successful. Brady is better now. I think I should tell Reese that Brady broke Peyton's TD record last year.

Answer 10

Brady

Answer 11

Brady has had things easy because his supporting cast is so good he doesn't have to do much to look awesome.  Manning is the best QB and toughest competitior.

Answer 12

tom brady obviously has a more succesful career he has 3 rings! and 50 td last year. peyton manning is also very good tho

Answer 13

More Sucsessfull: Easily Peyton

Better now: Tom Brady

Answer 14

Manny.

He is a record breaking, playmaker and one of the best game managers in football.  

Answer 15

Manning is more successful because he has better stats. Before 2007 Brady had never thrown for over 30 TD in a season, Manning does that routinely. Manning could have thrown more touchdowns in 2004, he barely played the last game of 2004 when he already had 49 TDs. Going into the last game of 2007, Brady was on 48, and he played the whole game just to beat the record. I think Manning is the better QB, and has been the better QB. Moss played amazingly and he was definitely the best receiver alst year. I definitely think that Peyton could have just as good a season with Moss on his team.  

Answer 16

Tom Brady by far. Manning is no scrub like his brother but Brady has 3/4 rings, wins about 12-14 games a year and never had a WR like Randy Moss in those super bowl years, whereas Manning always had Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne and only got 1 ring. Success is measured by winning. If it was measured by records everyone would be comparing Favre to everybody else but when you talk about best QB's right now it's always an argument about Brady and Manning.

Answer 17

Brady more Superbowl wins and much more effective with lesser receivers than Manning has ever had.  Look what Brady did with Moss and Welker?  Can anyone name the Pats 3rd receiver last year.  HMMMM...now with Harrison, Wayne, and Pollard, Manning could only win ONE SuperBowl.  Need I say more?