Who has more value headed to the end of the season, Mike Aviles of the Royals or Ian Stuart of the Rockies?

Question

I am looking at both..and they both have two position eligebility. Ian Stuart had his share of praise early on in the season and was a watch for candiate..Aviles came out and unloaded..who do you think has more value leading down the final stretch and into the playoffs?

Answer 1

Stewart has been lights out since his recall. His 3B/CI eligibility is important to me in a couple of leagues instead of Aviles. Stewart has the higher "prospect" rating and he would definitely be the one if I were deciding in a keeper league.

If you need Aviles SS eligibility, go for him. Both obviously have done very well. As another person said, they are both rookies.

Good luck. Unfortunately in a situation like this, all we can do is guess.

Answer 2

aviles has been a bright spot for the royals and he just got his long hitting streak snapped. i like aviles because he can play both 2B and SS and he's a better hitting option for his team.

Answer 3

Aviles is a better option, although both are rookies and the pitching will catch up to them soon.  

Aviles is a better hitter who is more versatile and he may be all that KC has before too long

Answer 4

aviles