Who has "the right to return"?

Question

Jews who have never been to Israel or the people who were displaced from it, and why?

Answer 1

The people of Palestine - it's historical name since at least 500 B.C. obviously have a right to reclaim their ancestral homeland. Jews only lived there in small numbers at any point in history. Non-residential jews obviously have to "right of return" since they've never lived there in the first place,what to speak of their venomous hatred of the Palestinians. All exilic Palestinians have a right of return,and to their own system of government.

Answer 2

Palestine had never been the land of Israel.

If you trace their origin , you will discover that they were mostly Kurds (with much common genetic features between them than any other nations) who moved to the fertile crescent "Mesopotamia" and then to Palestine and then to Egypt and back to Palestine but they never dared to return back to  Mesopotamia.

Jews invented the story of the promised land  that floods with milk and honey  in their books of myth to connect themselves to what doesn't belong to them.

Answer 3

my grandparents never set foot on the ground because their sires  were forced to leave not because they wanted to.

we're back home.

accept and deal with it ,friend.

Answer 4

The five million Palestinians displaced from it since 1948. And they also have a right to political self-determination.  

Answer 5

That's a very-very good question my friend.

And a tough one too!

OK, I am going to try and answer this lovely question of yours from where I stand.i.e. from a country that is far from the Middle East and away from the heat of fanaticism.

You see on one hand the Jews fought for their land and won, remember?

Even you can accept the fact that their Arab enemies did everything they could to loose that war. 99% of the Arab soldiers deserted their ranks making this easy for a squadron of blind and drunken sailors to win this war in the place of the Jews.

Nevertheless the Arabs did not fight well and the Jews won. Period.

On the other hand the Jews proved inadequate to govern that land.

Their serious lack of smart politicians gave the Army a decisive part in the every-day life of the Israelis.

That's the dumbest thing to happen in a modern country.

The Army cannot control a state. It is called a junta. I am sorry I got carried away.

Anyway although the Jews won back then, due to their inadequacy of creating a viable and modern country, with the help of those Billions of Dollars coming in  each and every year from the Jewish-Lobby of America plus the constant violations of human rights (and many-many other condemning factors like their obsolete and very dangerous Dimona nuclear reactor,illegal pesticides, etc.) had a result of placing Israel among the most brutal and backwards countries of our planet.

So if you ask me it is the duty of Israel to allow everyone that lived on that land for at least a hundred years to claim the land of their forefathers.

Saying silly and childish things like : God gave me that, makes people only laugh and give their support to the Palestinians.

So, my opinion is that Israel must change tactics, or else something terrible will happen there eventually, affecting other countries in the region too.

Greetings

Answer 6

Only the people of the land,namely the Palestinians. Jews have no right of return since it is not their country.  

Answer 7

The right of return is a fictional creation for fictional refugees. The special palestinians are not really refugees and really refugee status does not pass form generation to generation. The palestinians who left Israel where those who did not obey orders to annihilate Jews in 1948. Six months later arab countries went to the UN to declare them refugees when in reality they were just obeying orders to leave Israel if they did not participate in the promised quick annihilation.