Who has the edge, Packers or Vikings by positions?

Question

-DEFENSE-

Defensive line- even

Linebackers- Packers

Corners- Packers

Safeties- Vikings

-OFFENSE-

Lineman- even

WR- Packers

RB- Vikings

TE- even

QB- whoever has Favre.Without Favre it's even, maybe towards Vikings since TJ has more experience

Who will win the division and why?

Answer 1

OFFENSE

QB: Packers.  with or without Favre.

RB: Vikings.  hands down, no comparisson.

WR: Packers

TE: Packers.  who is the Vikings TE?  Donald Lee was great last season.

OL: even.  dead even.

DEFENSE

DL: Packers.  have have more depth and apply more pressure.  the Vikings have one solid pass rusher in Jared Allen while the rest focus on the run.

LB: Packers.  very fast and smart.

CB: Packers.  very physical and experienced.

S: Vikings. solid. known for getting interceptions.

it truly is a tossup between these two teams, but i firmly believe Green Bay will win the division looking at the balance and talent GB has on offense and defense.

Answer 2

I think you're list is pretty much correct, though I think the RB gap has closed considerably with the addition of Ryan Grant. I think if Brett doesn't play for either team, Packers would still have a slight edge just because Tavaris Jackson is not very good. If Favre plays for either team, though, that team would have the advantage and win the division.

Answer 3

Vikings got a stellar defense and good offense! Packers... not so much!

Answer 4

The Packers are a better team.  They return the same team as last year just with a different QB (probably).

Sooner or later the Vikings will have to throw the ball.  With their passing game they wont be able to play from behind.

Jackson sucks.  Rodgers who knows.  I wouldn't rely on either of them right now but at least Rodgers WR's don't suck.

Answer 5

Packers....vikings are good but they have no pass offense