Who is a better QB, Tony Romo or Peyton Manning?

Question

I Know that Tom Brady is the best but i just want to know who the second best is. If you think someone else is better, then tell me who.

Answer 1

Peyton Manning right now. but in 1 or 2 years, its going to be Romo

Answer 2

Ok first of all Peyton is better right now but Romo will be great in the future. {Peyton is my favorite player ever so no disrespect}

Second of all. Brady is only good because his offensive line is good. I've said that to so many people. Any QB can be good if he has time to throw. If their was only one O line member vs. 5 D line members the QB back will be sacked before he can even drop back. Brady got sacked a ton of times in the Super Bowl by the Giants because the offensive line broke down and let the defensive line get to Brady. I have a lot of respect for brady though he has worked hard to get to where he is today but nonetheless if he didn't have time he wouldn't be as good as he is. And that's the same with every QB in the league.

Answer 3

I would rather see the patriots offense on the field with 2mins left in the 4th quarter than Peyton and the colts.

im biased to peyton because i just dont like romo or brady..

sorry

1. Manning

2. Brady

3. sorry, and im not jumping the bandwagon, but favre impressed the heck out of me. and i really never liked him

Answer 4

Peyton Manning is better than him by a million miles. Peyton has started every year since his rookie season and he already has a ring. I would even take Drew Brees, Eli Manning, Ben Rothelisberger, Donovan McNabb, Carson Palmer or Brett Favre over him as of today and this season.  

Answer 5

Peyton hands down no brainer. Has Romo won a playoff game ?

Answer 6

As a Cowboys fan, I have to be honest and say Peyton Manning. Manning has been around longer (Romo has just 26 starts) and has playoff success and a Super Bowl ring.

Right now I would say Romo is the third best QB in the league. He has the potential to be great for a long time but has to cut down on his impulse throws and have postseason success. Which I think he will.

Answer 7

A quarterback is only as good as his teammates who are on the field with him. That being said I would have to give the all around edge to Brady in a dead heat with Manning. Romo, Favre, and Brees a close 3rd-5th. In just a pure skills competition, I think Manning would win hands down based on long throws, short throws, reading defenses and play calling on the fly. Romo and Young are definately most mobile and Favre-Brady a close 1-2 in arm stregnth.

Answer 8

Is this a joke?

Answer 9

Peyton Manning. he's probably better than Brady too

Answer 10

you cannot be serious...manning

Answer 11

Manning took a while to win in the playoffs and Romo has not reached that point yet, so it would be Manning. Tom Brady is very patient and never panics, so it probably the best. (did have at least one super bowl given as a gift by the league - Raiders never recovered!)

Answer 12

Manning.

Answer 13

Manning is way better than Romo  

Answer 14

Right now Peyton, Romo just needs to prove himself in the postseason and then we'll see who says what then.

Answer 15

Peyton Manning is by far the better QB becuase of his knowledge of the game and because of his ability to read and pick apart a defense. But if you mean statistically, Tony Homo(and yes I do mean Homo) will probably have a better statistical year because he has the ability to make plays and buy time with his legs.

Answer 16

Brady is so good he makes up the top 3 best QBs in the league

Answer 17

manny is better

Answer 18

I've been hearing this question alot now. Just the fact that this question is being asked now shows that people have accepted, even if they don't want to admit it, that Brady has solidified himself as the best QB in the NFL and now it's all about whose second best. My opinion... it's Peyton Manning... though, give Romo a few years and he might surpass Manning as the second best QB in the NFL.

Answer 19

Peyton Manning easily