Who is a better QB Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Question

Who is a better QB Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Answer 1

who just through for 4800 yards, 50 TDs, and 8 INTs? Brady

I am not saying that Brady is the saint that can do no wrong I am just saying that Manning has had Recievers throughout his career (Marvin Harrison COUGH COUGH) and has barely some years dished out 30 TD passes...Brady with no recievers (lead reciever Deion Branch COUGH COUGH COUGH!!!) through for 24-28 TD passes a season...Manning would have put up 21-24 nothing against Manning he is a great reciever...I am also not saying it is wrong that he had recievers and manning didn't I am just saying that as soon as the pats gave brady some recievers he broke the TD record...

Answer 2

Brady all the way. He has turned mediocre receivers into icons. Manning is only good because of his receivers, Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, etc.



Brady also has more rings.

Answer 3

I hate to say it but Peyton Manning. Just like the guy above stated, he has better stats than Brady. He didn't win those rings alone. Brady is overrated

Answer 4

Tom Bradys good because he's got the best receivers in the NFL. Peyton Mannings good because he's got some good receivers. Peytons not even the best quaterback with the last name Manning anymore.

Tom Bradys got the rings. Not entirely because of him, but he's got the rings.

As much as i hate to say it, Bradys better

Answer 5

Manning

with the offensive line and wide outs and the running backs that New England has i mean how cant any QB become successful there and with the killer defense there too they can win any game in any situation. Meanwhile the colts have the Offense but they suffer with injuries often but Manning still finds a way to win the ball game. plus the colts don't have the best defense. so i would give Manning the credit of being a better QB.

Answer 6

Brady!

Answer 7

Peyton Manning

Answer 8

Both washed up, once the leg injuries start a QB's days are numbered.

Answer 9

Eli Manning.

Better PASSER? Peyton.

Answer 10

manning

Answer 11

Im amazed by the level of retardation on yahoo...some of the worst answers I have ever seen are in this topic.

Answer 12

Tom Brady is way better, check his stats. and besides look three championships, and three rings= A FOOTBALL LEGEND  

Answer 13

Both have had their shining moments but... Brady has more rings to date, Peyton Manning has the better stats/records in most categories.  

Rings are more of a team measurement and individual stats more of an individual achievement so...

Peyton Manning

Answer 14

Tom Brady!

PS: All you guys are haterz

Answer 15

Peyton Manning. He is only 1 year older and has 15000 more yards, 100 more TDs and his rating is 2 points higher despite making more attempts.

Manning without his best receiver (Harrison) still puts his usual monster numbers. Brady without Moss puts above average numbers.

Marvin Harrison before Manning, average but not spectacular numbers.

Randy Moss before Brady, monster numbers besides 2 seasons with the Raiders when he did not make a true effort.

Answer 16

A lot of people are saying Tom because of the rings, but that is really a measure of the team not just one guy. I am gonna have to say Peyton. Brady has such a good team and such outstanding receivers its hard to not be good in NE