Who is a better RB for the Bengals assuming Rudi Johnson is on his way out?

Question

I had Kenny Watson as a backup on my fantasy team last year and he had a few solid outings for me when I needed it most. Now I am reading that "Perry is the only Bengals running back worth owning." If anything shouldn't it be a toss up between the two since they will likely split carries?

Answer 1

They should sign Shaun Alexander and see what he can do behind that tremendous O-line.

Answer 2

they are screwed no matter what no of them are that good

Answer 3

No perry will se majority of the time plus he can be a great 3rd down back

Answer 4

I think that Chris Perry is better.

Answer 5

I thought it would be Watson as well.  He was a big pickup for me last year when Ronnie Brown got hurt on one of my teams.  Apparently Perry's having the better preseason though.  I would pass on both of them for now.  Or pick both up and release the one who plays less.