Who is a better fantasy player, Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Question

Who is a better fantasy player, Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Answer 1

Brady absolutely no questions asked.  I would even say Romo is even better than Manning.  That is questionable but for sure Brady is better than Manning.

Answer 2

Brady...

They are the top 2, but Manning had knee surgery recently, and they are in transition with their wide receivers.  Marvin Harrison also has knee issues, and is in decline.

Some might argue Romo deserves high consideration, but Manning is a lock for 35+ TDs.

Last year's record setting season places Brady at the top.

Answer 3

Tom Brady is a better fantasy player and more importantly is a better NFL quarterback/player.

Answer 4

This year or over career?  This year it will again be Brady.  N.E. plays the easiest schedule in NFL history!  (doesn't seem fair right?)  Opponents have a 99-157 record from last year!  Brady still has one of best WR crew too: Moss/Welker/Watson/Gaffney etc.

Answer 5

I'm gonna say Brady

He has a lot more going for him

Brady:

Pros- Randy Moss, Wes Welker, Kevin Faulk (overlooked often, but a great receiving back), an easy schedule

Cons- Coming off a super bowl loss

Manning:

Pros- Reggie Wayne

Cons- Marvin Harrison is injured, should be out for the beginning of the season, CBs will be quick to cover both Wayne and Harrison (when he's on the field), as they are his favorite targets, moderate schedule: a lot harder than the Pats' walk in the park

unless you're ready to lose out on fantasy points in the beginning of the season until Harrison's back, Brady's the better option. Also, Brady's put up a lot of good numbers, and while he's not going to replicate his numbers from last season, I'd expect more out of him than out of Manning.

It's your choice :)

Answer 6

yea brady is  really good but this year they will be even on fantasy points ,brady wont have another year like he did last year. and  ROMO ROMO ROMO

Answer 7

I dont trust brady, partially cuz i hate him.