Who is a better player - Hleb or Berbatov? (please don't answer if you are an Arsenal or a Spurs fan)

Question

To make this as objective as possible, it is preferrable if the answers didn't come from Arsenal/Barcelona and Spurs fans

Answer 1

To answer the second part of your question I'd rather have Hleb as Liverpool are in more need of a player like him than Berbatov.

Answer 2

helb is a playmaker and Berbatov is an out-and-out striker. It is hard to contast and compare them. I think Berbatov is the complete striker and can offer more to a team that Hleb.

Answer 3

I think Berbatov is way better now a days. You barely hear people talking about Hleb and he made no achievements in the past few years while Berbatov is a great striker and I would prefer to have him play in my team rather than Hleb.  

Answer 4

Arsenal fan here, But your question doesn't make sense, Hleb is a right midfielder and berbatov is a striker, Its kinds like whole apples and oranges thing.

Answer 5

stupid question.

how can you compare a midfielder and a forward??

DURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Answer 6

Sorry I'm an Arsenal fan and although iv' liked Hleb for a while (stopped once he left for the money) iv'e always thought Berba was class and a better player than him.

Answer 7

Berbatov. He do create chances for his teammates and he is a good free kick taker and is strong in the air.

Answer 8

As KOLO says you cannot compare Hleb a midfielder to Berbatov a striker!#

However I know I would rather have Berbaov in my team anyday! He is a more valuable player and in my opinion gives more to the team than Hleb ever did!!