Who is a better player out of manning or tom brady.

Question

a better player

Answer 1

Regardless of what system either of them are on, you would have to give it to Manning.  Brady just has the team, coaches and the right division to be in.  Either way, you take either superstars recievers away and Manning outshines in every aspect.  He has a stronger arm, more accurate, more stable, while Brady is really only good for dump passes or short in and outs.

Answer 2

Manning

Answer 3

Manning is the offensive player. Brady is the system qb. He was given one season to light it up and he did well. Although, half the td's were yac and not Brady. Some amazing stuff was done by those receivers and sometimes it seemed like Brady just put the ball up there and Moss just snagged it. In 2002 Manning threw 8 td's in two playoffs games against Denver and the Chiefts. Then he lost to the Pats as usual. It was always the Pats defense that stopped the Colts from having more rings, not Brady. But it is Manning that has put fear into defensive cordinators over the last decade. Brady can't even be mentioned in the same sentence as Manning in my opinion, but he is an excellent qb. A great fit for the Pats system, but not an offensive juggernaut by any means. I think if Billiceck would have sat Brady on few times when they had monster leads last season, then Brady's great year would have lived on. I think it was an angry attempt to squelch the spygate scandal and they were pass happy. It's just an opinion, but when they almost lost the the Ravens last year, Manning had the Colts up 30-0 the next week in Baltimore and sat by the 3rd quarter. Manning is sick

Answer 4

<<<<<This Guy

Answer 5

For years Colt fans have pointed to Manning's records while Patriot fans have pointed out that if Brady had a decent WR he breaks records.  

The Patriot fans were right.

Brady, obviously.

For the first idiot, did Vinatieri kick 99 yard FGs or did someone get him close.

For Idiot #2,  yes, Brady is just a system QB with 3 rings and the TD in a season record.:rolleyes:

Funny how the idiots are afraid of e-mail.:)

Answer 6

well i dnt know but usually i go by the ring so i gues tom brady event tho his kicker got most of those wins for him.

Answer 7

Peyton Brady or Tom Manning

Answer 8

Oh good question.

Manning i think has the better arm.

Brady I think is a better manager of the offense.

Manning is a better technical QB, though I would want Brady leading my team.

Answer 9

peyton

Answer 10

Peyton is a way better quarterback. He got the arm and knows how to move out of the pocket when call to. Brady is smart but not as technical as Peyton. We saw in Super Bowl that he is not good outside the pocket and how slow he is. Plus once he got hit a couple of times he did not handle it very well.

Answer 11

MANNING ALL THE WAY!!!

b/c when Manning was in the Super Bowl he kept his kool and WON Brady choked and lost the game 4 his team. I would rather the Ginats win anyway

DOWN W/ BRADY!

Answer 12

Well since 2002 Brady is 5-3 against the colts .... therefore i have to give it to Brady!!!

Answer 13

no, no, no, idiots arnt you all Peyton Manning broke records by being a true sportsman.tom brady on the other hand ran up the score against teams that were in the rebuilding process and having a cheating a** coach always helps as well.

We all know brady studied the defensive calls of other teams cheated his way as well as randy moss way into the nfl record books so by this account Manning is truelly the better QB any Manning you choose.