Who is better, Xabi Alonso or Gareth Barry?

Question

I think Alonso is better. He is younger and has a better overall than Barry. So he is worth more than Barry. But why people rate Alonso's transfer fee lower than Barry's? Please don't be biased.

Answer 1

Xabi Alonso, one of the best passer in the world.

Answer 2

Xabi is a great player with a great future ahead..........http://soccergauge.blogspot.com/

Answer 3

Alonso.  His distribution is class.

Answer 4

I prefer Xabi but I cannot believe that Rafa has gone through all this if he doesn't think that Barry would strengthen the side. It's no secret that Stevie G is a big fan as well so it's good enough for me.

Answer 5

I think Xabi alonso.I hope Xabi Alonso coming fenerbahçe sorry my english is not good

Answer 6

Alonso's better, i think Barry's transfer fee is overvalued, he is overrated too. It's what you get with English players, too expensive.

Answer 7

Alonso

Answer 8

Xabi by a mile, I cant understand rafas want for barry????

Answer 9

xabi all the way. Why does everyone say that Barry is better. He plays for the rubbish. At least xabi plays for a good team.

Answer 10

alonso all day everyday, barry is english and rafa is planning for the future, thats why he bought an irishman and sold a englishman losing £8 million on the deal.

Answer 11

xabi is quality, however last season barry was the better player and has been for the last few seasons in fact.

We need alonso to find the form of his 1st few seasons with us, but theres no way i would sell him  

Answer 12

alonso by a kilometre

Answer 13

Alonso the one from liverpool right? he is freakin good...and he is champ

Answer 14

Xabi. I'm praying we don't let him go to Arsenal.

Answer 15

they are both exactly the same type of playas except xabi is younger an can score from his own half!!

Answer 16

Who cares? Neither are going to win anything with Liverpool.