Who is better QB?? Chad Pennington or Jeff Garcia?

Question

Look at what Garcia has done:

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/G/GarcJe00.htm?redir

Look at what Pennington has done:

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/P/PennCh01.htm

Note: Look at what Garcia has done without Terrell Owens.

Answer 1

Garcia.  Both have good ability, but Garcia's leadership is head and shoulders above Pennington's.

Answer 2

Garcia has proven he's the better leader and quarterback.  Pennington is a quarterback who has more physical gifts but Garcia gets more out of his.  

Answer 3

Garcia. He can scramble better, he's tougher, and he's come through in the clutch time and time again.  

Answer 4

pennington is more accurate but i would give Garcia an advantage with his ability to control the game and move out of the pocket

Answer 5

Pennington is garbage. The dude is very accurate no doubt, but he cant do deep routes if his life depended on it. I saw him do it just one time, but thats about it. Garcia is more fun to watch and a better game manager.

Answer 6

Garcia....Pennington has had flashes of greatness but is not durable.

Answer 7

Garcia

Answer 8

Jeff Garcia by a mile.  When Garcia gets the kind of talented WR's that the Jets have and that he had at Philadelphia, he will get even better, especially for fantasy.  garcia doesn't make 2 many mistakes.