Who is better crosby or malkin?

Question

Who is better crosby or malkin?

Answer 1

Evgeni Malkin is better.

Answer 2

both. but i love malkin. he has one of the best slapshots ive ever seeeen

Answer 3

they both suck

Answer 4

They are both equally amazing, but Crosby is more respected and gets more attention/credit. I'm so glad they are both on the Pens!!!

Answer 5

zetterberg

Answer 6

equal.  have you seen malkins slapshot???  like 400mph.  sid can see the ice like no one's business and set up plays in his sleep.  the pens are lucky to have both for the next 5 years, at least.

Answer 7

crosby.  evgeni malkinstein got completely shut down by pavel datsyuk in the playoffs.  at least crosby showed up.

I love getting thumbs down for speaking the truth.

Answer 8

Sidnevgeni Malkrosby!

Answer 9

Crosby

Answer 10

Well, I heard that Crosby is better at making pot roast, but Milkin can make a mean chicken casserole.  

better at what?  scoring, penalty kill (lmao), powerplay?

Erica: lmao.

Answer 11

Crosby because he is more of a leader and a better team player, he makes people around him good. Also Malkin did get shut down when he had to go against good players like Lidstrom, Rafalski, Zetterberg and Datsyuk which happens to everybody but he did absolutely nothingfor the penguins in the finals against those players and Crosby actually did something.

Answer 12

Crosby better playmaker,

Malkin the goal scorer

Answer 13

It's hard to say. Sidney is quick on the ice and he can execute a play perfectly, but Geno has the nastiest shot I've ever seen. To me, they're both equally great players.

Answer 14

crosbey.

Answer 15

So far it looks to be Crosby. Better playmaker. Better leadership capabilities. More consistent. Didn't choke in the Cup Finals. More well-rounded. Malkin appears to be the better shooter and maybe is a little more physical, but I'd take Cindy over him any day. They are both young, though, and a lot can change in the next few years. It will be interesting to see where there ceiling ends up being.

Answer 16

I think Crosby is.  At the moment anyway.  Both players will blossom even further so we'll have to see who develops into the big franchise player but from what I have seen, it's Crosby today and tomorrow.  Malkin made way too many mistakes in the playoffs for me to have much confidence in him right now.

Answer 17

Sidney Crosby

Answer 18

crosby! but i have to say malkin's slapshot is one of the best! crosby has the best intuition and reflexes on the ice out of all the NHL players in my opinion. but hey! im a biased pens fan!

Answer 19

I noticed all the Crosby votes got a thumbs down ...so I'll go with Malkin.

I think it depends on what your team needs. They are both Top 10 talents in the league.

Different styles compliment different teams. Put either one on the old mid to late 90's Devils teams and neither would score 100pts.

They both really just started out...too early to call.

Answer 20

Alexander Ovechkin makes them both look like AHL players!