Who is better for a 3rd or 4th WR in my NFL Fantasy? Patrick Crayton (DAL) or Anthony Gonzalez (IND)?

Question

My Current Roster:

Week 1

D McNabb A QB

K Smith A RB

L Johnson A RB

J Galloway A WR

N Burleson A WR

R Moss A WR

J Witten A TE

S Gostkowski A K

D Patriots A DST

J Cutler RS QB

T Bell RS RB

P Crayton RS WR

R McMichael RS TE

M Crosby RS K

Answer 1

Crayton b/c Terry Glenn is getting old and won't be able to perform for 16 weeks. Dallas will depend on Crayton to step up in his place. You should also trade Mcnabb and another pick for a better QB. He's too injury prone. And, LJ's overated.

Answer 2

A. Gonzalez by far!

Answer 3

I would go with Crayton because he is more liely to see playing time than Gonzalez. Terry Glenn is injury prone, and my prediction is he will lose his spot by week 3.

Answer 4

Difficult to say at this point. However, if I were you, I'd be worrying about RB rather than a 4th WR right now. I never keep two TEs or 2 Ks, so you could pick up Gonzalez and keep Crayton. You really need to deal with the RB position though. I don't know which K. smith you have at RB, but either way, you've got a handcuff at the position and that means you're a back short during the bye week at least.

Answer 5

gonzales,,he and peyton started getting into pretty good rythme  last couple of weeks last year think it'll only get better

Answer 6

I like Gonzalez more, but you have Moss, Gost., Def, And K. Smith already off in week 4, so i would stick with Crayton as he is going to be a bench player anyway and you may need help week 4.

Answer 7

I think Mark Clayton's awful year last year was a fluke (he had a preseason injury that lingered all season; the Ravens #3 WR Demetrius Williams and TE Todd Heap also missed most of the season with injuries, as did their top 2 CBs, which is why the Ravens struggled despite improving significantly in run offense and run defense last year), so I wouldn't count him out this year, but I'd rather have Gonzalez or Crayton.  I do think Crayton's the better player to have because he's #2 on the Cowboys, while Gonzalez is #2

However, I would trade one of those WRs for a better RB.  Both your starting RBs play for the same team and your only backup RB has never lasted through a full season in his career.  That's really going to be a liability, especially if the inflated passing stats and deflated rushing stats of last season were a fluke.

Answer 8

You want Anthony gonzalez as your 3rd receiver, because Patrick Crayton is only a returner and he is a backup to Terrell Owens, and he won't be getting any receptions hardly, plus Anthony gonzalez is a starter.