Who is getting a better deal in my Fanstasy Baseball Trade?

Question

I picked up Bruce when he came up hoping that he would have a hot start so i could trade him for a better player. But now he's struggling and I need a stronger outfield. Also, I need to clear space on my team as Peavy and Byrnes will be returning soon, so here's the deal.

I receive: B.J. Upton and Jerry Harriston Jr.

I give up: Jermaine Dye and Jay Bruce

I decided to ask for Harriston too because I want to make it seem like he's giving up a great player along with an injured player to get two good players. Do you think this is a good deal for me, and do think he will accept this deal? Most of the guys in my league are not very baseball savvy so I'm hoping for some luck.

Answer 1

Do it but instead of getting harriston get another OF because Dye and Bruce are hot right now, but in the end they would slow down Upton's stock is rising now so do it.

Answer 2

Good deal for you, Bruce looks like he is going to be a great player but the jury is still out on that, and you get a proven player back in Upton who qualifies at one of the weakest positions in fantasy

Answer 3

Get that done. ASAP

Answer 4

I'd try to get it done..

Dye was off to a good start but is slowing down.  Trade those two while they still have value and get Upton if he's willing.

Answer 5

bad deal, bruce is a good player and will be a big producer for you in the long term. bj upon is not better than bruce and dye. Do not do this trade