Who is more like Robert Redford in "The Natural" Josh Hamilton or Rick Ankiel?

Question

Who is more like Robert Redford in "The Natural" Josh Hamilton or Rick Ankiel?

Answer 1

josh hamilton.  haunted past and jungle power.

ankeil took performance enhancing drugs too.  dont think they were taking hgh in the 40's.  winner hamiton.

Answer 2

Since Roy Hobbs did neither steroids or crack, neither one is like him.

Answer 3

Josh Hamilton.  He has one of the most natural swings I've ever seen (except Griffey).  He swings so effortlessly and it just looks so good.  He really is a natural.

Answer 4

Neither one of them. Roy Hobbs had a great pitching career

cut short at an early age when a women shot him, and then

he comes up to the majors for the N.Y. Knights and only

plays one season........