Who is more of a monster, Victor Frankenstein, or his creation?

Question

I need to write an essay, and this is the prompt. Can anyone tell me what the ideas would be? and what would be the rebuttal

thanks!

Answer 1

Victor he was doing something he had no right to do. He was playing God and a lot of scientists today are just like him, if not worse.

Answer 2

I have read that last year in 7th grade, and we had to write an essay about it too. I said that Victor Frankenstein is more of the monster. Because think of it, he made the creation that killed the people he loved. But, you should decide it. :)

Answer 3

there is no one answer. write two papers each blaming a different person and put them together.

Intro

its the monster (ideas of paper one)

its frank (ideas of paper two)

similarity's and diffrances but choose one what makes him more monster

conclusion

Answer 4

Victor is a scientist looking to make an invention.  His monster is not evil he just doesn't know any better.

I think the real monsters are the villagers.  

Answer 5

I think Victor, because he's the one that created him in the first place. It wasnt a good idea, messing with life.

Frankenstien just did what his poor little brain could do. He had no idea of morals. He was just a monster. Is a lion responsible for killing people when he's let out of his cage? Or does the real responsibility lie in the hands of the person who let him out?

Answer 6

Whoa! Great question. I would say they are both montrous in some degree, but Frankenstein's creation had a lot less love, care, and acceptance in his life, so I would hold Victor much much more responsible for his deeds.

LuthienT