Who is more talented and exciting player? McCullum or Pieterson?

Question

My vote goes to Kevin McCullum.

Answer 1

pieterson

hes more consistent as well

Answer 2

McCullum is an explosive batsman....he is a very good pinch-hitter! He can turn a boring match into a very exciting one with his superb shots, so my vote too goes to McCullum form New Zealand!

Answer 3

Robin Uthappa & Rohit Sharma are talented players...

Yuvraj Singh & S. Sreesanth are exciting players...

Answer 4

McCullum is certainly more talented!!But Pieterson is more exciting Hence my vote is 50-50!!

Answer 5

Brendon Mccullum

i am not laughing at the 7th answerer Tommy and 17thanswerer kookee jr

who said pieterson is consistent and mccullum is one of the five innings(just said the opposite)

and kookee,who just looks at the stats,maybe mccullum isnt getting the hundreds but he keeps getting the 60's,70's,80's and 90's,seeing the performences since last year Mccullum has performed much better than pieterson,Mccllumcan do things which Pieterson can only dream of!!!

Last 10 innings of both players

Kevin P-4,13,110*,39,50,41,29,6,28,63*,8

Brendon Mccullum-17,60*,36,77,58,4,80*, 42,80*,35,40

Answer 6

mc cullum is more talented bcoz he plays the ball not the bowler

other hand pieterson always wait for a weak bowler not for a weak delivery

Answer 7

McCallum

Answer 8

McCullum

Answer 9

mucullam

Answer 10

McCulllum.  without any doubt whatsoever

Answer 11

McCullum 4 sure.Don't u remember his 158 knock for Kolkata knight riders.

Answer 12

McCullum is  more aggressive~

Answer 13

Both are talented and exciting players in their own right,

we have McCullum who loves to hit the ball as far as he can - and he hits them big!

and we have Peitersen who loves to show what he can do, hits them well and out the ground alot

theyre both good!

Answer 14

Well, Mccullum is more talented player, with an excellent consistency & is far experienced in his game. Pieterson, is also a good player, but will come out with time gradually.

Answer 15

Kavin Pieterson

Answer 16

when we talk Talented it is Pieterson and when we talk about exciting it is Mccullum

Answer 17

McCullum i like him Because he is playing well.....

Answer 18

pieterson.as the aussies will find out next year!

Answer 19

Pieterson is more talented, McCullum is more exciting.  However, if Pieterson plays his natural game he can be more exciting.  So my vote is Kevin Pieterson.

Did you just say your vote goes to "Kevin McCullum."?

lol

Answer 20

Pieterson!!

Answer 21

Test Match Situation:

Batting - McCullum - 38.9%; Pietersen - 59.1%

Bowling - McCullum - 0%; Pietersen - 1.6%

Fielding - McCullum - 71.8%; Pietersen - 15%

Overall - McCullum - 47.6%; Pietersen - 60.9%

ODI Situation:

Batting - McCullum - 43.5%; Pietersen - 82.3%

Bowling - McCullum - 0%; Pietersen - 1.6%

Fielding - McCullum - 82.7%; Pietersen - 31.7%

Overall - McCullum - 48.5%; Pietersen - 76%

Pietersen is one of all time great batsmen which McCullum is not.

Answer 22

There's no contest

Kevin Pietersen. Look at the stats, higher average in all forms of the game, more 100's!! and he's played a lot less games! Pietersen can do things which McCullum can only dream of! McCullum is a slogger, Pietersen has everything

EDIT- Hey Amusement Park i just have a couple of stats for you

Pietersen test average- 49

Pietersen ODI average- 49

McCullum test average- 32

McCullum ODI average- 27

McCullum more consistent LMFAO!!!!! do you know anything about cricket!! the HIGHER the average the BETTER the player you fool!!

I tried not to laugh at your answer! BUT LMAO!! your answer was SO funny!! LMFAO!!!

MORE STATS FOR MR IDIOT

McCullum average in the year 2006 (in tests)- 24. in 2007- 17. in 2008- 33,64

Pietersen average in the year 2006 (in tests)- 53. in 2007- 50. in 2008- 44.50!! LMAO!! Pietersen's average is higher!! LMAO!!

McCullum hasnt even ever hit an ODI 100!! you idiot!! he has had 1 good series!!! Pietersen is one of the best players in the world!! do you know anything about cricket?

ALL THE FACTS PROVE PIETERSEN IS BETTER!! LMAO!! you embarassing little sh*t

Answer 23

McCullum is an exciting cricketer but I feel he is pretty casual  because there comes a stage where he goes after everything

There doesnt seem to be a second dimension to his game

On the other hand, Pietersen is both talented and exciting. He plays in a very planned way, as the situation demands

Example, McCullum would go after Brett Lee even if Lee at the top of his game. Whereas Pietersen would watch Lee before actually going after him

But i like the mixin of names so I would say Brendon Pietersen because I want the aggression of McCullum at the start and at the same time the control of Pietersen to last throughout the innings.

Answer 24

very difficult to choose one, ok, according to me McCullum is a exciting player but Pieterson is more talented and excited.

i will go for 50-50

Answer 25

pieterson

Answer 26

pietersen

Answer 27

MuCullum is a kinda player who has all the shorts in the book & can be devastating to any bowler...

But Pietersen is a kinda player who is always trying to set the standards for himself n he respects the bowlers as well... so i guess...

Both are exciting

But if there is  NZ vs Eng Match i would wait for Mucullums batting more then pietersen.

Answer 28

I think Pieterson is more talented.

He is more consistent, relable as well as play more excieting game.

Whereas McCullum is one in five inning person.

Answer 29

lol...I guess you smartly mixed up both names but I think even though both of them are destructive on their day but Brendon McCullum's innings of 158 in first IPL T20 has left an everlasting impact on my mind & my vote goes to him.

Answer 30

I think you just covered yourself for everything there! Isn't Mccullum's name Brendon & Pietersens Kevin? lol, anyway, I think both are very useful players .