Who is more underrated all time?

Question

Steve Carlton or Stan Musial??? Both put up jaw dropping numbers and are mentioned far less frequently than many other all time greats in baseball history.

Answer 1

between these two, it seems that Carlton is more forgotten.  heck, i forgot about him until just now.  i rememer stan "the man", though.

Answer 2

Neither is underrated.

Both are just ignored

Greatness is not defined by the "Media"

Trust the everyday fan who knows what true greatness is..

Answer 3

its gotta be babe ruth he was a pretty good player but waaay underrated

Answer 4

they both are/were much better than they were given credit for. Stan played in the 40's and 50's before baseball became so popular and carlton played on the losing phillies, so neither is often remembered, but carlton winning 27 (i think) games for the last place phils who won only like 50 some games that one year? I think it was back in the 70's. Very impressive and very underrated. Good question.

Answer 5

this is the BASKETBALL section