Who is or was the greatest player, Scottish or foreign to play in the SPL or old 1st Division?

Question

try to answer from what you've seen and not what people tell you

Some possible or impossible options:

Henrik, Lubo, King Kenny Miller, Kenny Dalglish, Davie Cooper, Sally McCoist, Durrant, Baxter, Brian Laudrup, Nakamura, Di Canio, van Hooijdonk, Jorge Cadete, Gazza, Barry Fergusan, Paul McStay, George Best, Davie Provan, Brian McClair, Frank MacAvenie, MoJohnstone etc

Answer 1

my personal favorite would have to be naka

Answer 2

Drew Jarvie  

Answer 3

two many to say 1 or 2 but my favoirte  jinky larrson dalglish  

Answer 4

Jinky no problem.

Answer 5

davie cooper,richard gough,george young,willie johnstone,jock shaw, sammy cox, willie waddle, torry gillick, willie thornton, willie woodburn, johnny hubbard, billy simpson, eric caldow, alex scott, jimmy millar, ralph brand, don kitchenbrand, bobby shearer, billy ritchie, davie wilson, david provan, jim baxter, ron mckinnon, willie henderson, john greig, jim forest, kai johansen, willie mathieson, colin jackson, dave smith, william (sandy) jardine, eric sorensen, alex ferguson, orjan person, colin stein, gerry neef, alex macdonald, alfie conn, peter mccloy, derek parlane, alex miller, derek johnstone, tom forsyth, tommy mclean, bobby mckean, bobby russell, gordon smith, ian redford, john mcclelland, robert prytz, jimmy nicholl,  robert fleck, ian durrant, ally mccoist, chris woods, terry butcher, graeme souness, graham roberts, ray wilkins, mark walters, john brown, gary stevens, mark falco, trevor francis, ian ferguson, kevin drinkell, trevor steven gordon ramsay, andy gray, nigel spackman, oleg kuznetsov, david robertson, alan hutton, kris boyd, mark hateley, andy goram, stuart mccall, alexei mikhailichenko, duncan ferguson, gordon durie, brian laudrup, alan mclaren, basile boli, oleg salenko, paul gascoingne, jorg albertz, gordan petric, erik bo andersen, joachim bjorklund, peter van vossen, sebastian rozental, george mclean, alan morton, bobby brown, scot symon, ian mccoll (john miller mccoll), eddie rutherford, willie paton, john little, john prentice, george niven, max murray, alan mcgregor, carlos cuellar, nacho novo, kevin thomson, gerry dawson..

Answer 6

got too be McCoist

Answer 7

Henrik Larsson or Ally McCoist

Answer 8

Henrik Larson.

Roy Keane although didnt have a great time there if he joined earlier in his career, even about three years earlier he would have been great.

Answer 9

King Jim Leighton

Willie 'God' Miller

Big Red Mcleish

Neil Simpson

Drew jarvie

I could go on but then i'd be as bad as those clowns above me with their blue n green pish.............

Answer 10

Paul Gascoigne.  Genius.

Answer 11

Best Scot : Jimmy Johnstone

Best Foreigner: Henrik Larsson

Answer 12

Come on - what about Dave Mackay. Paul Gascoigne was good - but he wasn't at Rangers long enough to gain the top award - and d**n...he made the Bhoys roar with his 'flute playing'. That itself showed him as extremely unprofessional

Answer 13

the greatest scottish players  jinky baxter dalglish mcgrain jardine cooper



foreign players larsson lubo laudrup  

Answer 14

personally i would go for henrik.to be so consistent for so long and then to leave still at the top of his game will mean he will always be remembered as one of the best.would really have liked to see lubo at the club 5 years earlier and he would have been another celtic legend.

Answer 15

Jimmy Johnstone,Willie Baxter, the ones you have mentioned not forgetting Tommy The Bhoy Burns rip.

SOD IT THE GREATEST PLAYER WAS ANYONE THAT PLAYED IN THE 67 EUROPEAN FINAL FOR THE CELTS

all others have close comparisons,but great footballers none the less