Who is the NFL's most indispensable player?

Question

I would have to say Tom Brady. His backup, Matt Cassell, has never started an NFL or college game. He's the best QB in the game, and he is ultimately separates the Patriots from a possible 13-15 win team to a 5-7 win team if he goes out.

Answer 1

You could say the same about Peyton Manning with Jim Sorgi backing him up.

(Giants probably wouldn't of won the Superbowl without Eli either)

I would say Tomlinson, but that teams pretty stacked, they might be able to get by without him.

Answer 2

Peyton Manning. The best q.b. of his generation.

Answer 3

Brady-easy  Manning 2-  Hester 3

Answer 4

brady, romo, manning, larry johnson are the top 4.

brady: Cassell, 3rd stringer that was promoted.

romo: brad johnson, they are screwed if he is under center, period.

manning: sorgi? exactly. no way he can run that offense properly.

johnson: smith or charles, either way the chiefs lost 9 straight w/ out him and people are doubting LJ... (whispering) he plays better when he is pissed, so keep it up.

Answer 5

You mean the most indispensable to his team?

Orlando Pace. Last season he went down after the first game and the Rams sunk 3-13. Also their usually powerful offense suddenly became the 24th ranked and two of their offensive stars (Bulger and Jackson) got hurt because of a poor blocking.

Answer 6

Between him and Peyton Manning. Brett Favre may be another one. We'll see.  

Answer 7

Yes, but the Patriots still have Randy Moss and a great D.  I'd have to say Vince Young.  The Titans were terrible when they drafted him, and now have turned it around.  There is really no other Pro Bowl player on that team, besides Albert Haynesworth, whose future with the Titans is unclear.

Answer 8

I'm hoping that it is not Alan Faneca.

Answer 9

have to agree with you.