Who is the better QB? Mcnabb or Warren Moon?

Question

Friend is arguing that Donovan Mcnabb is/was a better qb than warren moon. Who do you feel is the better QB?

Answer 1

Why is this even a question.  I am a Steeler fan so I hated Warren Moon back in AFC Central days.  But this is no contest, Moon is the better of the two.  Moons arm was amazing he had a rifle arm and was very accurate, scrambles and improvises way better than McNabb and he wasnt made of glass.

Answer 2

I always liked Moon.  He was a great QB.  I wish he would have won a Super bowl, then he wouldnt be compared to the likes of Mcnabb.  moon vs mcnabb??? come on...moon by a mile.

Answer 3

Warren Moon

Rose Bowl Champion

5 consecutive Grey Cup Titles

Most passing yardage in NFL until 2006

Pro Football Hall Of Fame member

Canadian Football Hall Of Fame member

He did all this even though he was undrafted

what has McNabb done?

Answer 4

McNabb ofcourse

Answer 5

the one who's is in the HOF, Warren Moon

Answer 6

Warren Moon.

Answer 7

Mcnabb.

Although Warren Moon did much more for then game. He and Randell Cunningham (who is better than both moon and mcnabb) earned alot of respect for Black QB's, and opened alot of doors for players like Mcnabb.

Answer 8

Your friend is right. McNabb

Answer 9

McNabb (representing Cuse)

Answer 10

Moon

Answer 11

Moon was twice the QB McNabb is! He was more accurate, more mobile and ten times more of a leader! Give Moon this Eagles team and he probably wins the super bowl. d**n I'm glad hes retired I don't think I could stomach the Eagles winning the superbowl!!!!!!!

Answer 12

Brett Favre

Answer 13

without looking up the stats. i'd rather have McNabb as my QB

the dude is a winner compared to Moon

Answer 14

Warren Moon by a mile. Mcnabb has talent but is hurt every single year. Moon had a rifle for an arm and is an all time great. Also he was durable unlike Mcnabb.  

Answer 15

Warren Moon...McNabb is injurt prone...