Who is the better all-round fly half Dan Carter or Johnny Wilkinson?

Question

Who is the better all-round fly half Dan Carter or Johnny Wilkinson?

Answer 1

dan carter, nt coz m a kiwi bt an aussie.lol.

he can ingnite the backline n kick a penalty from 62 metres bet wilky cant even do 50

Answer 2

Dan Carter is DEFINITELY better...Wilkinson seems to getting a career out of being injured rather than actually playing rugby...People stopped rating Wilkinson after 2003, when he could play a decent game.

Answer 3

Dan Carter. No question about it!

Answer 4

Johnny

Answer 5

Daniel Carter

Johnny has not been world class since 2003 due to his injuries

Answer 6

Daniel Carter, he is the best, he is such a good play maker...  He controls the games...

Answer 7

i think Dan's the man!!  he has better distribution and pace than wilkinson!!!  probably about even with the kicking!!

Answer 8

Dan Carter

Great kicker, Great ball-player, Great guts

Simply Great!!

Answer 9

Definitely Dan Carter. JW was a bit of a ont time wonder.

Answer 10

At this moment in time Dan Carter is by far and away the better all round fly half, especially as JW has only just started playing again

Answer 11

I'm a huge JW fan- but can you be the best if your hurt all the time?????????????

Answer 12

they are both very good players with little to choose between the the two of them.here is some stats,Dan 15.1 points per test,Jonny 15.7per test.The major difference is the number of tries and drop goals,with Dan scoring .45 tries and .03 drop goals per test and Jonny scoring .1 tries and .4 drop goals per test.Conv Dan 2.84 vs 2.36 for Jonny and pen Dan 2.35 vs 2.36 for Jonny.Looking at the stats Dan is the more offensive and therefore able to score the tries whilst Jonny prefers to score from a distance,but then again the teams style of play also dictates the opportunities offered

Answer 13

Before the World Cup final of '03 Johnny was the best in the World and probably the best ever. However, because of his injuries, his lack of match play and the ascendancy of other players, he isn't even the best fly half in England. Charlie Hodgson and Andy Goode are both rated above him in team selection and several others are able to compete with him in the also ran position. Dan Carter is light years ahead of him and is currently the best in the World. I just hope that Johnny can find enough injury free time between now and the 2007 World Cup to get back to his best and make England a team to fear, not ridicule.

Answer 14

Dan Carter and i'm a South African

Answer 15

Dan Carter

Answer 16

easily dan carter. but jonny is winning on the looks scale

Answer 17

DAN the Man! The best thing is that he's still young and learning the ropes of at first-five... He will keep getting better!!

Answer 18

Neither, Charlie Hodgson is far the better player, Wilkinson is injury prone(like now) and Carter was not that good

Answer 19

dan carter is obviously hundred time better than that wussy pom.

Answer 20

i reckon JW is the better.

hes got paec, can pass, a very good tackler (when not injured) and then last but not least theres his kicking game which is 2nd to none.

Answer 21

I would go for Dan Carter, although JW's defence is better when he's fit!

Answer 22

DC by far, what people dont realize is that Carter can play defence just as well as Wilko, if not better, Wilkinson is a beast on defence, but Carter is even better, he once ripped the ball out of the arms of a foreward (J Cronje) near the goal line, took two steps and booted the ball a so it rolled into touch 80 meters downfield, also he creates so much on offence and can change a game in seconds, he dosnt really lose much to JW in goal kicking either, if you want proof, just watch his 61 meter kick against SA 3 weeks ago