Who is the better investment for the whole year? Jermaine Dye or Ryan Ludwick?

Question

Who is the better investment for the whole year? Jermaine Dye or Ryan Ludwick?

Answer 1

i like jermaine dye. last year he was great post ASB and has a solid track record. ludwick came out of nowhere, has been slumping lately, and has probably been figured out by NL pitching

Answer 2

I also say Dye. Even though he's aging, he's proved he can always hit. He has rarely slumped this year and is sometimes on a hot streak. When he's on a hot streak, prepare to get a few homers per game. As stated before, he has good post all-star stats. Ludwick has one good year (this year) and really hasn't shown he can stay consistent. He has his ups and downs and shouldn't be relied on for consisitency.